5 ms·
Yeah. The US is apparently already at ~50% antibodies, not counting vaccination. So, there’s a floor on the upside of the vaccine: It did no more than halve
by hedora 6y ago
Yeah. The US is apparently already at ~50% antibodies, not counting vaccination. So, there’s a floor on the upside of the vaccine: It did no more than halve deaths. We’re in the middle of a surge, and it looks like most of the remaining 50% will end up catching covid before being vaccinated, so the percentage saved by vaccination will continue to drop.
The ideal strategy without hindsight was conventional wisdom: Protect the vulnerable and stiff upper lip for the rest. That would have more than halved casualties.
With the benefit of hindsight, a 3 month shutdown while hospitals got their acts together (combined with protecting the vulnerable) would have roughly quartered the remaining deaths, but at far lower cost than the full shutdown.
This was predicted by some of the old-guard epidemiologists, which is why they were against the shutdown in the first place.
The cancel culture folks lumped them in with MAGA anti-vaxxers (I blame both sides) and got them censored by the big platforms. Here we are, with 100,000’s unnecessarily dead, trillions squandered, and many careers, businesses and educations ruined.
I suspect roughly zero people have learned a lesson from this. Hopefully I’m overly cynical.
- UncleOxidant 6y ago> With the benefit of hindsight, a 3 month shutdown while hospitals got their acts together (combined with protecting the vulnerable) would have roughly quartered the remaining deaths, but at far lower cost than the full shutdown. Where was this "full shutdown" you speak of? Not anywhere in the US. In Wuhan, and some other Asian countries, sure. Didn't we kind of have the 3 month shutdown-lite you're referring to? Mid-March through about June for most places were at varying levels of shutdown in the US. But recall things started opening up in June of 2020. And cases started rising again into July. > The US is apparently already at ~50% antibodies, not counting vaccination. Citation? That seems like about 3X the most optimistic numbers I've heard from credible sources.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hedora 6y agoAs for shutdown vs shutdown lite: No; the economy didn’t completely reopen in July. The recommendations from March 2020 were for more strict targeted shutdown protocols, but over a shorter duration (Strict reverse quarantines for nursing homes, but only for a few months for example.). The idea was to get less vulnerable groups to herd immunity faster. I’m saying a general, country wide shutdown for three months, concurrently with a strict targeted lockdown for about 5-6 months would have been more effective and cheaper (and, we’d have been done by last August, as the parent of my other post suggested.) Source for 50%: Wall street journal. We were above 33% (based on random sampling, not confirmed cases) a few months ago. This one from Feb predicted herd immunity a bit too early. They ran one with updated numbers last week, but I can’t find it: https://www.wsj.com/articles/well-have-herd-immunity-by-april-11613669731 https://www.wsj.com/articles/well-have-herd-immunity-by-apri...
- cujo 6y agoI suspect a lot of folks learned (in the US) is that if you have a president who politicizes a pandemic and shits the bed on leadership, the populous is screwed. Let's not pretend that rational discourse was ever an option, and the media isn't the place for blame.
- MockObject 6y agoI don't know. Seems like a sane, sober, professional, mature, and objective media would go quite far in moderating the overheated partisan rhetoric from politicians.
- pionar 6y agoNo, in the age of social media and the internet, the media is no longer a check or filter on partisan rhetoric from politicians.
- croes 6y agoYou can't really protect the vulnerable, especially when the vaccines wasn't developed. Any source for the 50% antibody claim?
- Izkata 6y ago> You can't really protect the vulnerable, especially when the vaccines wasn't developed. If true, then social distancing, masks, and lockdowns couldn't have done anything for the rest of us for the past year either. The argument for "protect the vulnerable" is that these precautions could be more targeted and so, hopefully, more effective.
- 1cvmask 6y agoAnd then we had excess deaths in NY State because Governor Cuomo FORCED nursing homes to take in infected patients! And then he gave immunity to the whole industry from liability if they didn’t take precautions. And he became the darling of the media and even won an Emmy. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/03/cuomos-nursing-home-scandal-is-only-getting-uglier https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/03/cuomos-nursing-home-...
- URSpider94 6y agoCDC data shows that more like 25% of Americans have antibodies to COVID, so your number is off by a factor of two. [https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#national-lab https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#national-lab] Additionally, you make a few glib statements that don’t really check out - you say give hospitals three weeks to prepare - how? There’s been a lot made of hospitals getting ready, but for the most part, the limiting factor for covid treatment has been how many icu care teams are available. More ventilators don’t help much if there’s nobody to use them. Second, I’m not sure how you protect senior citizens when everyone else, including the people who provide their care, is swimming in a soup of COVID.
- Izkata 6y agoLike a while bunch of places did in March and April last year: build emergency capacity during what was supposed to be only a short several-week lockdown. Instead, when the capacity went mostly unused during the lockdown, it was quietly dismantled and lockdowns continued. Also, we knew by April last year that ventilators were a bad choice: Doctors were jumping to it because of a specific weird symptom (blood oxygen levels impossibly low), but they had to keep turning the ventilators to higher settings to get an effect - to the point it was causing further lung damage. There's a bunch of less damaging ways to get more oxygen into a patient they'd been shifting to: https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/08/doctors-say-ventilators-overused-for-covid-19/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/08/doctors-say-ventilators-...
- Deregibus 6y agoPutting aside that these claims are presented without any evidence, “most” of 50% of the US population is a minimum of 82M people. ~31M have contracted COVID so far. That we’re going to see almost 3x the number of cases, concentrated in half the population, as we enter summer, and with 3-4M vaccines administered per day, is a pretty bold claim.
- cma 6y agoSomething close to a full shutdown was done in China, etc., not Florida.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y ago> The ideal strategy without hindsight was conventional wisdom: Protect the vulnerable and stiff upper lip for the rest. China, Vietnam, Australia and New Zealand used strict lockdowns to eliminate community spread, and then largely opened things up again. People in those countries have been able to live much more normal lives than people elsewhere during the pandemic. With hindsight, that was clearly the correct strategy: eliminate the virus, then reopen and keep a hawk eye out for any new cases.
- loveistheanswer 6y ago2/4 of those examples are affluent island nations with low population densities. Another one of those examples has been actively censoring covid information from the start, and thus cannot be trusted. As for Vietnam, it is an interesting case, and we don't have enough data to rule out cross reactivity or other factors playing a role. Extrapolating these data points to the entire world with wildly varying sociological, biological, environmental, and countless other factors and saying this is clearly the correct (and implicity achieveable) strategy for all 8 billion people on the earth is at best hypothetical.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y ago> 2/4 of those examples are affluent island nations with low population densities. Australia and NZ have densely populated cities, and what does being an island have to do with anything? Countries can close their borders. In fact, Australian states closed their borders to one another. > Another one of those examples has been actively censoring covid information from the start, and thus cannot be trusted. You don't have to trust the government. Just ask people you know in China what's going on there. Things have been mostly open for a year now, with no sign of the virus (outside of a few localized outbreaks, which have been dealt with through local lockdowns and blanket testing of the population). China is not the black box that many people think it is. > As for Vietnam, it is an interesting case, and we don't have enough data to rule out cross reactivity or other factors playing a role. Vietnamese people are not somehow immune to SARS-CoV-2. They're susceptible, just like everyone else. > Extrapolating these data points to the entire world This is the wrong way to think about this. These aren't data points generated by some semi-random process. They're countries that effectively implemented a strategy that we know should work, based on the basic principles of epidemiology. The virus is spread between people who are in close proximity to one another. If you drastically reduce contacts between people, the virus has far fewer chances to spread, and the epidemic recedes. If you do that long enough, you get down to a small enough number of cases that you can trace every single one and snuff out the virus completely. After that, you have to have strict measures at the border in order to catch imported cases, and you have to do regular testing in the population to make sure you don't miss the beginnings of any new outbreak. There's nothing to "extrapolate." The strategy works because of very basic principles of how the virus spreads. The only question is whether each county has the organizational capacity and societal will to carry this strategy out.
- kaitai 6y agoAs someone with a family member working in a hospital who still couldn't get reliable PPE after 3 months, I feel that you live in an entirely different universe than I do. Would that we would have lived in a country where PPE for nurses, physicians, and hospital workers were prioritized in summer 2020. Hah. Hospitals were not in a position to get their own; I saw them jockeying for shipments from China and Korea and it's just ludicrous to expect people to get their PPE in bidding wars that involve calling in favors from the chief cardiologist's wife's uncle who owns a factory in China.
- captainredbeard 6y ago> The cancel culture folks lumped them in with MAGA anti-vaxxers (I blame both sides) Agreed