4 ms·
> it seemed like everyone I interviewed with was a caricature of narcissism and delusions of grandeur I don't know what it is, but something about the position
by freedomben 6y ago
> it seemed like everyone I interviewed with was a caricature of narcissism and delusions of grandeur
I don't know what it is, but something about the position of authority and power of being an interviewer really does change people. It's a modern-day Stanford Prisoner Experiment[1]. I've been on both sides quite a bit, and it's remarkable how people flip like a light-switch when you enter that room. There are exceptions of course. Those people who it doesn't affect are the ones I like to work with. Although, it seems those most interested in being on the interviews also seem most affected.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
- ertian 6y agoThere may be something to what you say. But on the other hand, there's that old adage: if you meet an asshole one day, you met an asshole. If _everybody_ you meet during the day is an asshole, then _you're_ the asshole.
- bartread 6y agoI picked up on that phrase too, and it made me laugh. I've worked in places where often interviewers seemed more interested in proving how smart they were - and particularly how much smarter than the candidate they were - than in assessing whether or not the candidate is suitable for the job. It smacks of insecurity. My current company, regardless of how good or bad a candidate is, everyone knows that they are to be treated with respect and kindness, and they also know that if they don't treat the candidates well they're going to get a bollocking for it. First impressions definitely cut both ways, and word travels. If you treat candidates like crap don't be surprised if your stream of applicants dries up. Unless you're a FAANG you really can't get away with that sort of behaviour.
- dkarl 6y agoTo add some opposite perspective to this, jobs interviews are extremely stressful, and it's really, really, really hard not to psychologically trigger people. Even if you tell people ahead of time that you're going to ask a lot of questions about a variety of topics to get a well-rounded picture of their skills, including a lot of things that aren't strict requirements for the position, even if you tell them it's a conversation more than a test, even if you tell them that virtually all successful candidates have gaps in their knowledge that will come up in the interview, even if you explain all that and do your best to come off as easy-going and approachable, still. Still. A lot of people will panic and freak out the instant they hear something they're not prepared for. In an ideal world you would only ask questions that no qualified candidate could possibly have difficulty with, even under severe stress, but there's no way to do that. An additional complication is that interviewers can't just walk away knowing whether the candidate can do the job. They need to give a more complete evaluation of the candidate so the hiring manager knows what to do if the candidate negotiates for a higher salary or asks the company to match another offer they've had. This often depends on "nice to haves" such as advanced SQL skills or the ability to quickly assess the big-O complexity of an algorithm and figure out how to improve it.