3 ms·
It sounds like an Apple-directed decision. Is Reddit next?
by kactus 5y ago
It sounds like an Apple-directed decision. Is Reddit next?
- Mindwipe 5y agoIt does. It doesn't fit with the published iOS terms, but as we've seen before, Apple frequently ignores the published App Store terms during approval.
- tinus_hn 5y agoOr it’s a “we’re selling to Microsoft” decision. Who knows.
- jacurtis 5y agoYep I think this is influenced by the potential/likely sale to Microsoft. The timing makes more sense. So to clarify for people who don't use Discord or don't understand the article. What Discord is announcing is that now they will start marking entire SERVERS as NSFW. Keep in mind that server owners have been able to mark CHANNELS within a server as NSFW for a long time now and the iOS app has respected that (when you enter an NSFW channel you must be logged in, not a guest, and must explicitly agree each time you enter). So the blocking of NSFW content in the iOS app has been around for a while. A server that is full of NSFW content would simply have an NSFW block on every channel. This would meet Apple's censorship requirements and Discord has been meeting it for a while. Nothing new here on the Apple front. What is new is that Microsoft is interested in Discord. Recently Discord has made the news for fostering violent or NSFW content (most publicly from Wall Street Bets, which was the first time lots of Wall Street investors had heard of Discord). This change to internally-dictating NSFW servers seems like a way to make Discord more attractive to companies like Microsoft in a sale. Someone like Microsoft doesn't want to be looked at as fostering or promoting bad content, so these protections are ways to heal that image. Again, the change here isn't the introduction of an NSFW blocker. That has been around for a while. The change is that now Discord themselves will flag entire servers as NSFW. Previously it was up to server admins/owners to mark the individual channels on their server as NSFW. Now Discord is taking a lead to control/censor/block this content.
- Mindwipe 5y agoIf this was the motivation it seems unlikely that this would only apply to the iOS app and not to the Android app or the web.
- clscott 5y agoReddit clients on iOS already have to filter out NSFW content unless the viewer is logged in and has some settings applied to their account. This is an Apple policy not a Reddit policy https://www.vice.com/en/article/78k8yb/reddit-ios-apps-disappear-nsfw-content https://www.vice.com/en/article/78k8yb/reddit-ios-apps-disap... Edit: added the url I meant to use in the first place
- pksebben 5y agoAndroid here, that link is busted for me unless I install the app. seems like a reddit problem to me
- Sandvich 5y agoI help make one such Reddit client. There’s an invisible rule that you can’t show users the NSFW toggle or even mention that it’s on the website. We had a toggle that only lets you turn it off if it’s on, and that alone was too much. We also got rejected once because the top post that day had the word “fuck” in it. That was a fun one.
- PurpleFoxy 5y agoTelegram has it that you have to log in to the web one and switch a toggle which will unblock content on the iOS app. Everyone just assumes iOS the app doesn’t allow it so the setting is spread via word of mouth. It’s honestly insane.
- everetm 5y agoReddit already censors all nudity related subreddits from r/all. Historically that was only enforced on r/popular.