12 ms·
>>Imagine buying shares on the NYSE and next week you’re in prison!! So that is sensible I think. If you give your neighbour some money and he goes and buys a
by gambiting 6y ago
>>Imagine buying shares on the NYSE and next week you’re in prison!! So that is sensible I think.
If you give your neighbour some money and he goes and buys a gun with it and kills someone, you can be held liable in that scenario(depending on the intent, on how well you knew what he was going to do etc etc etc).
If you give a company money(investment) and they go and destroy the Amazon illegaly.....your hands are clean?
I mean, obviously I understand what you mean. I own some shares myself. But there has to be some middle ground between "100% responsibily, straight to jail" and "give money to people who do bad things, have 0 responsibility".
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI'm assuming - hoping - that if could be demonstrated that a LLC was open about trying to engage in illegal practices, and the investor knew that before investing, then the investor could be charged with facilitating crime.
- sokoloff 6y agoLots of companies operate in a grey area. PayPal, Uber/Lyft, AirBnB, and others were all open about “disrupting” which is code for breaking regulations that some people don’t agree with. All four of those companies have made my life better and I’m glad someone invested to make them happen.
- iudqnolq 6y agoI'm sure people say the same about drugs
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt was entirely possible to achieve the same disruption without breaking laws, so think instead of the opportunity cost - the damage done to the markets, granting wealth to people who demonstrated sociopathic tendencies and blatant disregard for the law, allowing those people to follow their principles and abuse their workers/"partners" at scale, and erosion of public trust in local governance. All of which could perhaps be avoided if the investors were afraid to be associated with such scummy business practices, and instead pressured aforementioned startups to stay fully above board while realizing their vision.
- sokoloff 6y agoTo test that with a simple example, could you describe how Uber could plausibly disrupt medallioned cabs in NYC without breaking any laws?
- roenxi 6y agoYou're describing a world where quite possibly no-one would be stupid enough to start PayPal, Uber/Lyft or AirBnB. Limiting risk is one of the most counterintuitive laws that has ever stuck, and one of the most devastating for the poor countries who didn't adopt it fast enough. Without those protections it would be far too risky to invest in companies that people weren't intimately involved with. The scope of human activity would be limited to things that could be achieved with a small business. While not necessarily the end of civilisation, it would be a huge change. And quite likely knock down one of the ladders (a well balanced stock portfolio) that people use to move up into the middle class. I'm not a fan of the idea. It entrenches class divisions and probably shrinks the middle class. It raises difficult questions of how retirement would be set up too, it would be much harder to organise an independent retirement without access to the share market.
- drdec 6y agoThat could get very complicated very quickly if the company is included in a popular index fund.
- Stranger43 6y agoone version would be to make sure that fines is paid in freshly raised (and dedicated) capital and not from the operating budget, or that shareholders are made financially responsible up to the value of their shares for criminal fines against the company. If you combine that by making should have known the company was doing things illegally an good enough reason for the shareholders to sue the responsible executives into bankruptcy and you might see a change in behavior. The problem is that when all of the costs comes out of the operating budget there is very little reason for the general assembly to hold the board responsible and if the board is not held responsible neither will the executives.
- doctor_eval 6y agoThis seems like an awesome idea, at least on the surface. I’d say fines should be paid in issued capital - I’m going to be thinking about this for a few days I think! Several problems remains however. Simply knowing that the company was breaking the law isn’t sufficient for a shareholder to be able to do anything about it. If you own <5% of a company’s shares[0], you have basically no way to change the behaviour of a company even if you know it’s wrong and want it to stop. Also, the value of a privately held business is difficult to compute. Although setting fines as a percentage of issued capital rather than a dollar value would ameliorate that. Finally, what would the government do with those shares? If the government simply destroys them then the actual value of the remaining shares won’t change. And the market for privately held shares isn’t huge. Still I love the basic idea. Can’t imagine it happening though, nobody wants to be held accountable. [0] if you’re a shareholder with less than 5% of shares in Australia you basically have no right to access anything other than the annual reports, so your ability to even know what’s going on is extremely limited. Don’t know if it’s the same in other countries.
- Stranger43 6y agoWhat i mean is that the shareholders should be able to reclaim lost value from any CEO who can be found to should have known the company was breaking the law, in civil court. The shareholders should be held financially responsible for any fines not levied directly at the board or the executive team, hence why their liablity should be capped to the value of the shares. The point is to force the large institutional investors to really care about the integrity of the boards they elect, so it might be worth putting in an lower limit to exclude retail investors with trivial amounts along with holders of non-voting shares from liability. The government would not be holding or owning the share they would be paid their fine in USD raised by the company from either newly created shares, or fresh investment in the case it's not publicly traded. And if they cant it's up the current owners to either pony up loose all of their investments. It should be up to the company fined to market those shares not the goverment. Remember that issuing shares without generating investment money devalue the existing shares, which is the point of the operation. IT might not be the one true solution but letting fines be paid from revenue disincentivize the owners from caring that much about legal fines.
- doctor_eval 6y agoTo be clear, I think there are huge problems with how corporations (and by extension the directors) are able to act with impunity, but most of those problems would be resolved by proper enforcement of the existing laws. I can’t see how investment can work if the shareholders were made accountable, but even if this became law, nobody would actually be thrown in jail under the current hands-off regime that seems prevalent in the Anglosphere at the moment. The fact that directors and CEOs have so much control over a business, but that it’s extremely difficult to hold them to account, is very bad IMO. But changing the law won’t fix anything if the law itself is not properly enforced.