2 ms·
The author posts some charts about wealth, then writes: > Paul paints a rosy picture but doesn't mention that incomes for lower and middle-class families have
by kortilla 6y ago
The author posts some charts about wealth, then writes:
> Paul paints a rosy picture but doesn't mention that incomes for lower and middle-class families have fallen since the 80s.
If you don’t know the difference between wealth and income, maybe you shouldn’t be blogging about these topics.
This is not meant to be some low-brow dismissal. How can you have any serious discussion when two completely different things are used interchangeably?
P.S. a chart that shows shares each class’s percentage shares of total wealth is pointless. It doesn’t actually tell you if the middle class is getting poorer. The middle class and lower class can have a constant inflation adjusted wealth (or even wealth outpacing inflation) and this chart will still look bad if we have more people moving into the upper class.
- alexgmcm 6y agoIt's probably due to the issue that Piketty noted in his book, getting reliable and comprehensive data on wealth is far, far harder than doing so for income. I agree with your criticism but it doesn't seem entirely honest when the "hollowing out" of the Middle Class has been a well observed phenomenon for at least the past decade if not several more.
- randomdata 6y agoHow has the "hollowing out" of the middle class been well observed when the data required to observe it is unreliable and shallow?
- alexgmcm 6y agoYou can usually infer quite a lot from income data anyway given that wealth and income tend to be quite closely related. Obviously, there are exceptions but in general there is a strong correlation. Furthermore, Piketty and other researchers have gone to great lengths to get reliable wealth data despite the difficulties. The difficulty of performing these investigations rigorously is why I would prefer to trust studies from professional economists rather than a hot-take from a blog.