4 ms·
The correct solution to this is for official banking systems to out-compete cryptocurrency by providing the advantages that it actually has, e.g. pseudonymous a
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
The correct solution to this is for official banking systems to out-compete cryptocurrency by providing the advantages that it actually has, e.g. pseudonymous accounts that can't be frozen or seized without proving the commission of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law.
Obviously this is approximately the opposite of AML, but everybody keeps demonstrating that AML doesn't work. So we're better off to just give it up and take the advantage of a formal financial system with the properties that people will be able to get from cryptocurrency regardless, without the energy waste of Bitcoin et al.
Because then people will use the official financial system, cryptocurrency will be less valuable, and less energy will be wasted mining it. Which is more than we're getting from privacy-invasive and ineffective AML rules.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> this is approximately the opposite of AML, but everybody keeps demonstrating that AML doesn't work It's odd to make these claims simultaneously. That one, AML doesn't work. But that two, crypto's value statement is in circumventing AML. Which, per the first claim, doesn't work. I get that the needle can be threaded by holding that an ineffective AML system can still be annoying. But if it's circumventable, that's just a cost. Which means we're comparing transaction costs versus fundamental aspects of differentiation. At the end of the day, most people aren't money laundering. Having everyone who is money laundering self identify on a public ledger might be the solution the problem is looking for.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> It's odd to make these claims simultaneously. That one, AML doesn't work. But that two, crypto's value statement is in circumventing AML. Which, per the first claim, doesn't work. The trouble is that the baseline level of inconvenience doesn't phase a criminal enterprise, because to even exist it already has to incur the cost of operating unlawfully and risk being shut down and compensate employees for the risk of being charged with a crime, regardless of AML. But the AML rules don't only inconvenience people who are really doing something wrong. There are obvious privacy problems with associating every purchase anyone makes with their name, and chilling effects for what people are willing to buy. It creates friction in things that aren't illegal. And since legal activity is so much more common than illegal activity, a little bit of inconvenience multiplied by the entire population is a lot, whereas a little bit of inconvenience multiplied by a couple of outliers is not. So the cost is more than the benefit.
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoI agree that AML is an onerous exercise in security theatre. But a large part of it involves tracking and tracing, not preventing.
- justin66 6y ago> The trouble is that the baseline level of inconvenience doesn't phase a criminal enterprise, because to even exist it already has to incur the cost of operating unlawfully and risk being shut down and compensate employees for the risk of being charged with a crime, regardless of AML. Operating an illegal enterprise in such a manner that cash can make it past AML measures and eventually be spent by the enterprise's owners, and the concomitant problem of structuring the enterprise's bookkeeping and tax reporting so it has enough plausibility to avoid prosecution, is more than an inconvenience. It's the central business problem the owners of those enterprises face. Talking about their business costs and risks "regardless of AML" doesn't really make a lot of sense. > But the AML rules don't only inconvenience people who are really doing something wrong. There are obvious privacy problems with associating every purchase anyone makes with their name, and chilling effects for what people are willing to buy. It creates friction in things that aren't illegal. This problem, the effects of which you're wildly overstating, has little or nothing to do with AML measures. (You mentioned a chilling effect on things that aren't illegal - are we just talking about stuff that people don't want their spouses to see on the credit card bill?) It's true that every purchase you make without cash will have a lot of detail associated with it, stored electronically and held by the banks and credit cards processors. This all predates modern AML rules by decades. You would have to do something very unusual for one of your transactions to "create friction" with your bank under the guise of AML rules. If it has ever happened to you, I'm super curious about the circumstances. Insofar as AML and other more modern, security-related rules might inconvenience ordinary people, they tend to affect people when opening an account, not when transacting.
- throw123123123 6y agoAML prevents very little money laundering but imposes a huge cost on everyone. Before 9/11 it was possible for a foreigner to open a bank account in the US. It's now been 20 years since it is required to physically travel to the us to open a bank account. Do you think that increases crypto demand or decreases it?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> it is required to physically travel to the us to open a bank account One, why does a non-American non-resident need an American bank account? Foreign banks can hold dollars. And two, plenty of American banks open accounts for overseas non-Americans. > Do you think that increases crypto demand or decreases it? Why is this a bad thing? An edge case is being addressed through a novel product. Win win.
- throw123123123 6y ago> One, why does a non-American non-resident need an American bank account? Foreign banks can hold dollars. HackerNews "its just rsync" level comment > And two, plenty of American banks open accounts for overseas non-Americans Literally 0 without physical presence. But I'm very much welcome to be proven wrong here, can you give me a bank that opens accounts for non american non residents?
- lazide 6y agoAnd why would the regulators allow that?