7 ms·
Perhaps worryingly the same is true in CS papers also. I genuinely think there should be a "No code? No Data? No Paper" rule instated from the top.
by mhh__ 6y ago
Perhaps worryingly the same is true in CS papers also.
I genuinely think there should be a "No code? No Data? No Paper" rule instated from the top.
- nick_kline 6y agoHa! Perhaps you have not published a theory paper. I'm on the systems side but theory is real too, even if there is no perf test. Systems papers can benefit from code and data though ;-)
- mhh__ 6y agoPut it this way, I have read a lot of papers that are basically pure theory (~5-10 pages of mathematics) but with some graphs of how effective the theory of at the end. Again, no code, no error bars, no data etc.