4 ms·
Maybe they patented it to stop anyone from implementing it, did you think of that?
by gaius 15y ago
Maybe they patented it to stop anyone from implementing it, did you think of that?
- vacri 15y agoAfter all, Apple does have a strong tradition of altruism!
- gaius 15y agoWell, it would be bonkers for them to have this "feature" when no other handset manufacturer did.
- thisisblurry 15y agoOther handset manufacturers could license the patent to use it, if Apple allowed it.
- mortenjorck 15y agoApple has a strong tradition of making the best possible user experience. Imagine the following scenario: 1. Sony Ericsson invents the camera-disabling technology instead of Apple. Pressure from Sony Pictures results in its implementation in a new SE Android phone. 2. The MPAA catches on and begins requiring theaters to install the technology while lobbying for laws that require it to be implemented on phones and cameras sold in the US. 3. Other mobile manufacturers start implementing the technology just in case the MPAA's lobbying succeeds, and to maintain relationships with content providers. 4. Apple, despite really not wanting to damage the user experience of its phones, is forced to implement the technology as well, as the industry has mostly adpoted it and Apple's content partners are using this as leverage in negotiating iTunes deals. And so here we have the alternative, where Apple has foreseen this and patented the technology to keep the industry from adopting it and forcing Apple to make a less-enjoyable product.
- albemuth 15y agoAnother scenario: Certain venues will not allow mobile devices unless they have iDisable technology. That's a win for the user I guess...
- vacri 15y agoThere is absolutely zero reason why SE and Apple can't be swapped in your hypothetical, especially given that SE has a much smaller market share than Apple. Apple's vertical integration also cuts out things users want - do you like pornography? Lots of people do. It's very popular. Where it's illegal, there are black markets for it. But where it can, Apple puts roadblocks in the way of these users' experiences. What about iTunes being required for the iPhone? Lots of people absolutely hate it and many screeds have been written about the horror. Not exactly "optimal user experience". Hell, I like to have the browser that comes default on my operating system to do fullscreen, but no, it has been decided that for "optimal user experience" Safari will not fullscreen, so I have to download another browser... Apple is not altruistic. Apple have their game plan and are running with it for the betterment of Apple, not the general user. That's great for some people, but it doesn't mean that Apple is altruistic.
- ghostDancer 15y agoYes you are right and the new bill won't be used against bloggers who embed a video. I'm afraid i've heard that song. I think Apple wants the content providers on its side (which is legit) so this can be another brick on its side against the rest. For that being valid i think they will have to enforce it.
- bryanlarsen 15y agoThey can make it expensive for somebody to implement the feature but they cannot stop anyone. Google for "United States vs Besser".
- cbailey 15y agoThe article hints at this possibility.
- napierzaza 15y agoI trust Apple for many things, but not that. Patenting ideas is something that is certainly not always done for sake of using the tech. So I wouldn't assume they're going ahead with this. Likely an engineer came up with the idea and they patented it.
- billybob 15y agoIn that case, they could get nice PR points by 1) announcing "we patented this to keep anyone from using it" and/or 2) donating the patent to the EFF or someone similar.