I gave both a listen after reading this comment. To my ear, the difference is just that her voice much more mature as a 31 year old than it was when the song re

I gave both a listen after reading this comment. To my ear, the difference is just that her voice much more mature as a 31 year old than it was when the song released 12 years ago and she was 19, and that naturally makes it harder to believe the small-town highschool themed lyrics. Her voice is too deep to sound like a teenager anymore.