5 ms·
> How does such an obvious fallacy command such purchase among smart people? Swift is talking about "music" as an original work. Patel responds with an irreleva
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> How does such an obvious fallacy command such purchase among smart people? Swift is talking about "music" as an original work. Patel responds with an irrelevant point about digital copies of music.
Your quotes don't support this analysis. There's plenty of original music available on the internet. Enough to call it an endless amount. Weirdly, you point this out yourself immediately after accusing Patel of a fallacy.
The fact that people will pay for Taylor Swift's music against a landscape with other music does not actually support the idea that Taylor Swift's music deserves to be paid for, either. People will pay for all kinds of things. https://satwcomic.com/clean-living https://satwcomic.com/clean-living
- selykg 6y agoI think there's a limited amount of good entertaining (to me) music available on the internet. Look, I can record a song and release it on iTunes (and all the others) using Distrokid. This doesn't mean it's good music that people will listen to, or would sell at all. Art is subjective obviously, but when you like something you know you like it, and when you don't like something you know you don't like it. But just because there's a ton of music out there doesn't make it good, or therefore valuable.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThere's certainly an endless amount of content on the internet, but it's not an endless amount of content you enjoy or seek out, so paying for the content you like is a way to incentivize the creation of more content that you like in a sea of content that you don't. 720,000 hours of new content is uploaded to Youtube every day, and none of it is the 90 minute movie I want to watch right now.
- sellyme 6y ago> it's not an endless amount of content you enjoy Hard disagree. There's an endless amount of that too. It's just filtering it out from the rest that's the difficult part.
- munk-a 6y agoI'm not a huge taylor swift fan but people who work in an industry with market disruption and the networking effect shouldn't throw stones. I'm a big fan of a number of artists personally - some headliners like RTJ and The Prodigy, and some less well known folks like m|o|o|n and bioxeed - there's a lot of good music out there but it can be quite hard to promote music and actually get it into peoples ears. That is a part of the business of music, as much as we might wish it wasn't - and it's exactly the same with other forms of art. Notoriety does help drive value since it will force people to take your production more seriously than someone hawking paintings at a farmers market - even if their paintings are technically excellent and moving. Record labels often try to stand up rando pop groups - sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't, but those groups that manage to stay around for more than a few months do have talent that supports the large marketing campaigns being thrown behind them - they may not be the most talented out there, but a large number of people genuinely enjoy their music.