3 ms·
"It should also be painfully obvious at this point that a more passive approach does very little." That's not really true. We have seen reductions in many type
by giantg2 6y ago
"It should also be painfully obvious at this point that a more passive approach does very little."
That's not really true. We have seen reductions in many types of pollution in the last few decades. Not all of it is forced on people through laws. Much it of comes about as improvements in technology that provide efficiency and cost savings. You can see this is the use LEDs, better fuel milage (before the mandates), adoption of solar panel roofs (in areas that don't mandate it), siphonmatic toilets vs wash-down toilets, etc.
"There's nothing totalitarian about holding people responsible for the long term damage they do to the environment."
I generally agree. The issue us whether an international organization can hold other countries accountable. This could be a major sovereignty issue, especially when the law does not explicitly define what is legitimate consumption or use and what is ecocide. For example, does lithium mining constitute ecocide? It causes environmental damage, but is then used in some industries that might reduce impact in other areas (electric vehicles).
- Retric 6y agoGlobal CO2 emissions where higher in 2019 than 2010, higher in 2010 than 2000, higher in 2000 than 1990 etc. We aren’t fixing the problem. Now, you might look a such trends and say it’s fine everything is going to work out, but I think that’s hard to justify. Some local trends look promising, but advanced economies outsourcing manufacturing and thus CO2 emissions isn’t actually helpful.
- giantg2 6y agoSure, if you want to pick just one metric that might be true. Do you have the per capita metrics? I don't know what it would show. Maybe it's higher than before due to more consumerism, maybe it's lower than in the past due to technology improvements. What about all the other pollution like mercury, sulfur, etc? All I'm saying is that the general trend has been the adoption of cleaner technology over time, and that some of it is from efficiency or costs as opposed to laws. One example would be diesel electric trains vs the old coal powered steam engines - way cleaner, more efficient, easier to maintain, and less water usage. "Some local trends look promising, but advanced economies outsourcing manufacturing and thus CO2 emissions isn’t actually helpful." I completely agree. Much of it has been a shell game. Without true authority over those manufacturing countries, they will likely play a shell game. The real issue will be the lack of definition of what constitutes ecocide and putting that determination by an international body against the sovereignty of the offending country.
- hirundo 6y agoIn the United States CO2 emissions per capita have been on a downward trend since the 1970s. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/carbon-co2-emissions https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/carb... To the extent that long term thinking is a luxury, the U.S. is doing well because it can afford that luxury. An effective solution might be to make everyone else at least as wealthy so that they can afford to do the same.
- myrmidon 6y ago> In the United States CO2 emissions per capita have been on a downward trend since the 1970s [...], the U.S. is doing well This is very misleading, because US CO2 per capita numbers are (still) very high, and only surpassed by a few oil states and ultra-rich enclaves (picture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions_per_capita#/media/File:CO2_emissions_per_capita,_2017_(Our_World_in_Data).svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...) With over 15 tons/capita/year the US is doing FAR worse than e.g. EU or China (which are at ~9). This suggests that "making everyone else at least as wealthy" is very ineffective in decreasing emissions. It seems very clear to me that any effort spent on reducing domestic emissions will have MUCH higher ROI than e.g. sponsoring the rainforest, or supporting Indian green energy projects. This is because cutting emissions from 15 to 10 tons seems (evidently?) much more feasible than e.g. getting from 10 to 5 (same gain).
- giantg2 6y agoOne thing to point out is those numbers also include CO2 from consumption of products. So some of the CO2 listed under the US is actually produced in China but attributed to the US. If a lot of the products in the US are imported from China (or have a trade deficit in general) then the US will be assigned the CO2 numbers from the places doing the exports. It's possible that the numbers would be lower if the products were produced domestically since there are stricter requirements and the price of goods would be higher (reducing consumption). Consumption is really at the heart of it all. It will continue to grow as the population does and as the world continues to develop.
- akvadrako 6y agoNot everything is about CO₂
- Retric 6y agoFair point, but most forms of pollution are fairly local. If a country wants to ruin their ground water we can complain on humanitarian grounds, but it doesn’t directly impact the rest of the world.