2 ms·
I guess the two real questions are... Where is the line between ecocide and legitimate consumption of resources? Do other human rights or ecocide take precede
by giantg2 6y ago
I guess the two real questions are...
Where is the line between ecocide and legitimate consumption of resources?
Do other human rights or ecocide take precedent when they conflict?
- OgAstorga 6y agoI’d start with the ones that are clearly doing irreversible harm. Think of a coal burning plant to produce electricity or deforestation of hundreds of acres in the Amazon to build more IKEA furniture.
- curryst 6y agoThat's still not very clear. Almost anything is reversible on a long enough timeline. Coal can be replenished on a long timeline, and the CO2 can be scrubbed. Until it can't, but it's rather spurious to try to assign blame to a single point. The coal plant is emitting CO2, but they'll say "well, it would have been fine except for trans-oceanic shipping". The shippers will point to the coal people. Likewise, the Amazon can be reforested. Maybe not at the rate were cutting it down, but it's not as though trees will never be able to grow there again. There needs to be a more nuanced decision around these. I'm with you, those things are bad and they should stop, but I would prefer to have a coherent framework we decide based on. I don't want to arbitrarily decide based on who can sway public opinion.
- Quanttek 6y agoPolly Higgins proposed the following definition to the International Law Commission: "Ecocide is the extensive damage to, destruction of or loss of ecosystem(s) of a given territory, whether by human agency or by other causes, to such an extent that peaceful enjoyment by the inhabitants of that territory has been severely diminished” [1] [1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/257552825_Protecting_the_planet_A_proposal_for_a_law_of_ecocide https://www.researchgate.net/publication/257552825_Protectin...
- giantg2 6y agoThat opens up even more questions in my mind. They want to hold people accountable for things they have no agency over? "...whether by human agency or by other causes..." The definition is still very vague and subjective. The people running the court in Europe might see deforestation in Brazil as severely diminishing peaceful enjoyment. I would say the farmers clearing that land for agricultural use would argue that they are peacefully enjoying the land now that they modified the ecosystem to be more hospitable to their way of life, crops, and animals. We could even go as far as to say that every city meets this definition as nature has been replaced with buildings and many of the animals have been greatly reduced or eliminated.