4 ms·
Hot take: A bit more totalitarianism is not a bad thing. Currently, mainly outside of the US, companies have too much of a free rein to do whatever they like -
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
Hot take: A bit more totalitarianism is not a bad thing. Currently, mainly outside of the US, companies have too much of a free rein to do whatever they like - in Brazil and China it's even government mandated. Corporations destroy the environment while not paying their dues, and they need to be reined in.
This does NOT directly affect the general population, which should be the most afraid of totalitarianism or a 'strong' / 'big' government. But the general population has a relatively small contribution to environmental destruction.
- hirundo 6y agoMaybe a bit more isn't terrible, but how do you limit it to a bit? History seems to describe that slope as slippery.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Currently, mainly outside of the US, companies have too much of a free rein to do whatever they like - in Brazil and China it's even government mandated. Huh? China is not known for its laissez-faire business environment, or for being uninterested in environmental quality. Reality is pretty much the exact opposite on both dimensions. And obviously there is no location in the world in which environmental destruction is mandated. You must have meant something else (?), but I can't figure out what it is.
- Verdex 6y agoNormally I don't get bent out of shape if someone makes their point with poorly chosen words. But seriously: > A bit more totalitarianism is not a bad thing. No, what you want is increased government effectiveness with respect to environmental responsibility. This can be achieved without totalitarianism AND IN FACT must be achieved without totalitarianism if it is to be effective at all. Can we stop or change a totalitarian government? Well, by definition no we can't. Only the totalitarian government can do that. If we have a totalitarian government that decides to protect the environment today, then we also have a totalitarian government that can decide to trash the environment completely tomorrow. And given how many assholes seem to like to grab for the reins of power within totalitarian governments, I don't like our chances of maintaining a benevolent, environmentally responsible totalitarian government for long enough for us to actually protect the environment. The global totalitarian government doesn't help the environment. We need global consensus that humanity would like to live on a non-garbage fire earth and then governments that are able to enact the will of the people. Anything else is going to quickly result in greater, long term environmental damage.
- 127 6y agoGovernment is mostly the problem it tries to solve. Increasing dictatorial power just increases corruption. That's a terrible gamble to make that the people in charge would just based on random chance agree with you that the climate problem needs drastic measures. You will never know what kind of a dirt-bag manages to climb to the top. It never seems to be the people you actually want.
- jiriknesl 6y agoHot take: If something is a good idea, you don't need a totalitarianism to convince people to value them and change their behavior. If people don't change their behavior, it isn't either that good idea, or the person is not good in convincing others to change their behavior. Of course, there are multiple factors, like shortterm vs longterm vision; competition with someone who is less ethical, ecologic, etc. But overall, totalitarian regimes don't have a good track record of longterm & ethical success, quite the opposite. As many things as possible should be handled on individual level and volutarily and as little as possible on centralized level with using force. This is an approach, that allows cohabiting of people of different opinions, cultures, etc.
- Nasrudith 6y agoAnybody presnting totalitarianism as a neccessary alternative is either a fool or a bastard to be disposed of at the earliest convenience. The object of power is power and not even loyalty keeps you safe from totalitarians.
- Daho0n 6y agoIn a few words you both praise totalitarianism and pretend that it's mainly outside of the US that companies have too free rein to do what they like! Wow, the world is a crazy place but this....