6 ms·
We have Deepwater Horizon/BP oil well disasters, companies raising foods crops using fertilizers and herbicides, and people eating hamburgers. All of those imp
by sokoloff 6y ago
We have Deepwater Horizon/BP oil well disasters, companies raising foods crops using fertilizers and herbicides, and people eating hamburgers.
All of those impose environmental destruction at some (very different) magnitudes. Which of those must a world leader prevent in order to avoid running afoul of the tribunal? If everyone avoids Deepwater Horizon scale events, are we done, or do we start to go after cow farts next?
- StavrosK 6y agoI don't understand the point you're trying to make here. Are you saying "drawing a line for crimes is hard"? Yes, lawmakers are intensely aware of that. Or are you suggesting that we shouldn't try to fix any problems because we can't fix all the problems?
- sokoloff 6y agoI'm saying that once you build up systems like this that they rarely self-dismantle once the important job is done, but rather grow, self-perpetuate, and consume whatever resources are available in an attempt to do whatever is next most appealing. No one wants 100 Chernobyl, Deepwater Horizon, Bhopal events or generalized global warming. Lots of people want their food, energy, and modern conveniences at affordable prices. Those things are inherently in tension and creating an international tribunal which can, with the benefit of hindsight and evolving viewpoints, make judgments about whether someone violated an inherently and intentionally unspecified level of environmental care 20 years previously is more than a small amount troubling to me.
- michaelt 6y ago(a) There could be a slippery slope to a lower quality of life - like curtailing meat production; (b) the threat of that would prevent governments from signing up; and (c) without governments signing up, the scheme won't work.
- stinos 6y agodo we start to go after cow farts next Is this not actually roughly of the same order as the other events you mention? The impact of all livestock being bread globally is not exactly neglectable when it comes to global warming, land use, nitrouse oxide deposition.
- sokoloff 6y agoYes. In fact, it might even be seen 20 years from now as being more damaging than the others. If that's the case, would we want 2021 world leaders to be hauled in front of such of a tribunal in 2040 for not doing enough to curtail beef production? That seems capricious, impractical, and therefore undesirable.