3 ms·
in the second case, there clearly is no "next" number in the reals as there is in the naturals, and that insight gets right at the heart of the concept of count
by xyzzyz 15y ago
in the second case, there clearly is no "next" number in the reals as there is in the naturals, and that insight gets right at the heart of the concept of countability.
I think you missed the point. There is no "next number" concept in the rationals either, and yet they're countable. There is "next number" concept in the first uncountable ordinal, and, as the name suggests, it is uncountable.
- pash 15y agoYou're right. The "next number" test (under the natural ordering) makes the concept of density obvious, not countability. So I think I've given credence to the notion that those who claim to find something obvious might not fully understand it. Or at least not at four in the morning. (Oh, and a point that Stephen Abbott made in his wonderful intro analysis book now springs to mind: proofs are useful also as a check on our intuition.)