3 ms·
> Using the FPGA for complex simulations like physic? Would that make any sense? The graphics card is specialised for this and has better cost/performance. Gra
by pjc50 6y ago
> Using the FPGA for complex simulations like physic? Would that make any sense?
The graphics card is specialised for this and has better cost/performance. Graphics cards basically are specialised gaming hardware optimised as much as possible for that use case.
Trying to teach games programmers to use FPGA tooling would be a spectacular disaster. Oh, and FPGA toolchain-targeting is to a specific device; you probably don't remember the early days when games would target a specific model of 3DFX card, but that's what you'd go back to. Upgrade your hardware and you need recompiled versions of all your games.
The one case where it might make sense is if you focus on latency to a brutal extent. DisplayPort on one side of the FPGA, wired game controller (NOT USB) on the other. A unique experience that's hard for normal systems to replicate.
- hutzlibu 6y agoI have never really done low level programming, so excuse my ignorance. (for example I was not aware "FPGA toolchain-targeting is to a specific device", which is a very great hurdle only maybe enabling something like this in game consoles) I know that gpu's are mainly optimized for games, but aren't they still general purpose computing units? (which is why nvidia put a special physics unit into their GPU's) So the idea as I understand it, is with FPGA's your logic is directly in circutry - which in theory beats general purpose units. So my actual question would have been, if this would allow for more complex simulations. Because most advancement in games just seem to be in making them look prettier, but not more complex and just faking complexity. But I really like the idea of an advanced voxel engine, for example. But by your input it seems FPGA's as of today, are probably not the way to get practical improvements there and rather focus on the GPU.