6 ms·
If you read a bit farther down, his "personal backup" is 200TB and he's pushing up 300GB+ every single day. That seems...abusive and excessive for a residential
by TylerE 6y ago
If you read a bit farther down, his "personal backup" is 200TB and he's pushing up 300GB+ every single day. That seems...abusive and excessive for a residential line.
- tyingq 6y ago> How much are you uploading? >> About 650gb a day Though he did buy 2 separate gigabit lines, each with a $200 setup fee. Apparently the service is 940mbps down / 35mbps up, per line. So it sounds like he would be running the upload at full capacity 24/7, on both lines. Edit: Updated since I read the service was 940/35.
- morrbo 6y ago940/35 and advertising that at 1gbps is part of the bs that needs to change worldwide. Either make a law it has to be a full duplex 1gbps connection, or a cap that the upload has to be at least 1/3, 1/2 (anything but 1/10th like it is here in the UK on average) of the advertised speeds. Having your upload gimped to ~30x less than your download, but it still be advertised at a gig just really rubs me the wrong way, residential or not.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jacoblambda 6y agoThat may be the case but they seem to have made it as apparent as possible that they would be using the high bandwidth. Hell not only did they pay for the installation of a second gigabit line to their house, they seem to have repeatedly requested clarification that there were no data caps and no throttling. I don't think spectrum has any ground to stand on here as it seems that the user in question went out of their way to clarify that what they were planning on doing was acceptable prior to paying for not only an additional line but the cost of running said line as well. This not only didn't set off any red flags for Spectrum but they reassured the user that this wouldn't be a problem. I don't know how you make it any more clear that you plan on using the internet plan to its full capacity other than that.
- TylerE 6y agoThey can "clarify" as much as they want until they're blue in the face. It's what's in the contract that matters, and every residential ISP contract I've ever seen has acceptable use limits, tells you not to run a server, etc. The ultimate catch-all is language to the effect of "activity that negatively impacts other network users" or some such.
- tartoran 6y ago300GB is arguably acceptable use. If they don't like people going over a threshold then they should write down a clear number (even) in fine print, *acceptable limit should be under 300GB or under 200GB or whatever limit works for them. Just because the marketing wants to sound one way they should not confuse a customer who wants to use the service they purchased
- TylerE 6y agoIt's pretty clear from the first paragraph of their acceptable use policy... 1. Use. The Service is designed for personal and family use (residential use only) within a single household. Subscriber agrees that only Subscriber and Subscriber''s authorized guests in the same household will use the Service. Subscriber is responsible for any misuse of the Service that occurs through Subscriber''s account, whether by a member of Subscriber''s household or an authorized or unauthorized third-party. Subscriber will not use, or enable others to use, the Service to operate any type of business or commercial enterprise, including, but not limited to, IP address translation or similar facilities intended to provide additional access. Subscriber will not resell or redistribute, or enable others to resell or redistribute, access to the Service in any manner, including, but not limited to, through the use of wireless technology. Spectrum reserves the right at its sole discretion to immediately suspend, terminate, or restrict use of the Service without notice if such use violates the AUP or the Terms of Service, is objectionable or unlawful, or interferes with Spectrum''s systems, or Internet Network, the Internet, or others'' use of the Service. It's a 35mbit up connection. His usage reprents over 95% utilization 24/7.
- wincy 6y agoI do this much traffic every day and Google Fiber doesn’t care at all.
- TylerE 6y agoDown or up?
- tyingq 6y agoFurther down in the thread he mentions it's 940mbps down, 35 mbps up. That would mean he's got both lines pegged for upload 24/7.
- cma 6y agoThat's not that much upload per line though, someone streaming or video conferencing in 4K or a bit higher all day could come close and be a legit consumer use.
- dboreham 6y agoStreaming all day 4K isn't consumer use.
- wanderer2323 6y agosays who?
- crooked-v 6y agoYes, it is. Consider a large house with an 8-person family (two grandparents, two parents, four children of varying ages 12-18) and it would be pretty easy to have at least one 4K stream active 16-24 hours per day every day. And that's strictly looking at active engagement, not even 'somebody leaves Blue Planet II running in the background because they find it soothing'.
- TylerE 6y ago
- crooked-v 6y ago> abusive and excessive If it's excessive, why did they advertise and sell the service to him with the claim that it was capable of handling it? This is just the usual bigcorp gaslighting with an "UNLIMITED" service that actually has limitations not included in the advertising.
- TylerE 6y agoThat's not really what was sold though, and you know it. HE didn't buy a dedicated line, or a business class line.
- tartoran 6y agoNo, the marketing is deceptive! They should add a fine print with the actual cap
- TylerE 6y agoIt's really quite clear. There is no firm cap. But they're not required to allow usage not consistent with a single residential customer, or effecting other users of the network.
- crooked-v 6y ago> But they're not required to allow usage not consistent with a single residential customer, or effecting other users of the network. That's not unlimited service. That's "limited service, except we won't tell you what the limit is until after you've already reached it".
- pessimizer 6y ago> usage not consistent with a single residential customer What do these words mean when the premise of this thread is that we're talking about a single residential customer? Is there a hidden meaning that I'm missing? > or effecting other users of the network. Isn't this a function of the quality of the network and completely out of the control of the customer?
- onion2k 6y agoUsing the service you paid for within the limits set by the provider cannot be excessive. "Excessive" would, by definition, require exceeding the set limits. He's definitely an outlier on the usage, but someone has to be the highest usage customer. Why not this guy?
- zbrozek 6y agoAbusive of what? Excessive by what standard? If someone is sold a plan without limits then what's the problem here?
- gumby 6y agoHow so? Why shouldn’t someone back up their data?
- totalZero 6y agoIf he paid for this service then why is it abusive? Charter could take some of cash he is paying every month and install equipment to alleviate the neighbor's concerns.