4 ms·
There are oddities with windows on a mac that make it seem like an overall worse experience. The trackpad driver apple supplies is sub par, there is no way to e
by asdff 6y ago
There are oddities with windows on a mac that make it seem like an overall worse experience. The trackpad driver apple supplies is sub par, there is no way to enable tap to click that I can tell at all (much to my chagrin as the artificial trackpad clicking on new macs gives me wrist strain due to having to smush your finger on a flat unmoving piece of glass). Mouse control on windows is also terrible. You set your scroll on a mouse to something like 4 lines or whatever, anything so you aren't just wheeling the thing out trying to get down the page, then you unplug the mouse and the settings carry over to the trackpad and it scrolls at lightspeed. I think in general windows is simply a poorer OS from a ux standpoint too, and the regular users have gotten used to this terrible experience. There is a lot of perceptual lag and hiccups just navigating the system, even on a beefy workstation with 4 cores >3.0ghz each which makes no sense to me. It makes no sense why windows explorer should even have delays. Why the start menu should have a delay. Not sure how regular windows power users tolerate this OS. It's as clunky as I remember XP being despite the hardware I'm trying these days being way more powerful; 20 years and no ux experience because microsoft knows people and companies will buy it anyway. Software seems in general to be slow to start, and slow to stop, in contrast to mac os, which must strive to be a better user experience if it is to poach customers from microsoft at all.
That being said, take a game that's been ported to both systems and run your mac in bootcamp with windows, and its not uncommon to pick up a good 10-20fps at least on games. I'm sure enterprise software especially the adobe suite runs a lot better on macos, because there was more engineering effort optimizing this port. I remember TF2 was most sriking on my 2012 macbook pro. On the mac OS side I was getting like 30-40fps on medium settings. Decent, I guess, for an ancient game. On windows in contrast, I was pushing 90fps, and it looked a lot better. That was the case for every single game I've tried.
The hardware drivers for things like CPU, GPU, the meat of the system, are much better on windows because the manufacturers just spend more effort building better drivers for this far larger market. Apple specific-sourced hardware that isn't an intel chip or some discrete GPU, like the trackpad experience, the display experience, how the fan is calibrated, are all subpar entirely on windows because Apple doesn't care to improve the bootcamp drivers. They are known to be supar, and on some Macs, the community even recommends their own drivers to use instead of the bootcamp ones, because Apple doens't care about the bootcamp experience.
- codetrotter 6y ago> I'm sure enterprise software especially the adobe suite runs a lot better on macos, because there was more engineering effort optimizing this port. The very first version of Photoshop was written on Macintosh and then later ported to Windows. But it would be interesting to know what the lineage of the code of the current version of Photoshop is. How much of it was written on OS X and macOS, and then ported to Windows, and how much is written on Windows and then ported to macOS. I wish I got to browse the version control histories of Adobe Photoshop and Adobe Illustrator some day. And also to talk with people who wrote these programs and hear them tell about it.
- computerex 6y ago> It makes no sense why windows explorer should even have delays. Why the start menu should have a delay. Not sure how regular windows power users tolerate this OS. It's as clunky as I remember XP being despite the hardware I'm trying these days being way more powerful; 20 years and no ux experience because microsoft knows people and companies will buy it anyway. I use Windows for work everyday. I don't like it as much as Linux or osx but I can't say that I have issues you are describing with start menu lag or windows explorer. And that's with several phpstorm/pycharm instances open along with like a dozen services running in docker. There are many problems with windows, but I don't think performance is one of them. Also it was a very long time ago, but XP was one of my favorite OS's. I think that was the last time where I could look at my process list and tell you exactly what each process is for.
- sokoloff 6y agoThose lags are exactly what we experienced. Click on start menu, get a blue spinner. Folder in explorer? Same. Click on the settings panel, get a spinner. And not for 100ms, but for a second or more. Now, this was on a fresh install, so maybe some cache needed to be built, but it was maddening. We did it in part to benchmark some games which I do suspect will work better in Windows.
- joshspankit 6y agoSomething is seriously wrong there. Even on an ancient computer once I turn off menu and window animation the start menu and small folders open with 0 spinning and probably less than 20ms. Maybe your “fresh install” has a bunch of bloatware and virus scanners?