3 ms·
Why is the NY Times accusing Israel, or any external party, without any evidence? Israel didn't take responsibility, and they're basing their whole story on an
by fortran77 6y ago
Why is the NY Times accusing Israel, or any external party, without any evidence? Israel didn't take responsibility, and they're basing their whole story on an unnamed source.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThe evidence is the officials the Times spoke with, who are anonymous to us but not to the Times. You don’t have to agree that this is sufficient, but it’s considerably more evidence than spewing random facts.
- bopbeepboop 6y agoIt’s only more evidence if you trust the NYT. Given that a NY Supreme Court ruling called some NYT “deceptive” and “misinformation”, the NYT presenting purely reputation based evidence is a negative to some readers.
- fotta 6y ago> ... Israel publicly declined to confirm or deny any responsibility. But American and Israeli intelligence officials said there had been an Israeli role.
- fortran77 6y agoAnd who are these alleged officials? That was my point.
- fotta 6y agoAssuming that the sources are trustworthy, and I trust the NYT in their due diligence on this, what incentive is there for the sources to lie about an admission of responsibility? Personally I don’t see one. If it was the opposite I might be more skeptical.
- celticninja 6y agoIn general these sources are known employees of these agencies whom the journalist knows and can vouch for. However the idea is they would never give up their name. These same people may sometimes be quoted directly but we don't know. So the journalist believes the source that's why it is printed. If it turned out to be demonstrably incorrect then next time you don't trust the journalist and the journalist doesn't trust the source. Remember this is a 2 way street. The intelligence agencies want everyone to know it was them, but they can't go claiming credit in public,so you get an unnamed source.
- budg6 6y agoThey could have done an anon twitch stream atleast. Its 2021...who needs newspapers and journos. They are outdated information surfacing systems.
- celticninja 6y agoYes because a random twitch stream is going to be believed. The newspaper and the journalist have credibility. If you dont understand how the media and politics/government work then I can't educate you on that in this comment section.
- Thorrez 6y agoEdward Snowden was originally an unnamed source. It's pretty common.
- kazinator 6y agoUnnamed sources are par for the course for journalism. Sometimes journalists receive information only on condition that the source remain anonymous, and they have to work with that.
- exegete 6y agoIsrael does seem to be taking responsibility. Israeli “public radio took the unusual step of claiming that the Mossad intelligence agency had played a central role.” https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/11/israel-appears-confirm-cyberattack-iran-nuclear-facility https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/11/israel-appears...
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoIsrael has obvious motive for making attacks on Iranian infrastructure. Portugal has no such motive for attacking Texas. Having motive of course isn't the same thing as being guilty but does make for an obvious place to start looking. It's also possible that the Times has some information that they cannot source at this time. Or they're just making things up, in which case, keep this story in mind next time you read some story in the Times that has no credible source attributed but fits a narrative you're interested in hearing. Pretty much anything coming out of the media these days needs extra examination for their own set of motives.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]