4 ms·
I had some time to dig deeper into the methodology of the paper used as the basis of the claim. One curious thing they did was normalize income in a way that a
by bumby 6y ago
I had some time to dig deeper into the methodology of the paper used as the basis of the claim. One curious thing they did was normalize income in a way that a single person making $58k/yr was counted as making $100k/yr by the nature of them being single. Now that makes some sense in the context of the way poverty is defined in part by the number of heads in a household, but it can certainly be misleading when defining classes by income. Here’s the strange part to me: a couple with no kids need $163k combined to meet upper class. Add me kid to the mix and they need $256k combined. According to their methodology, these all equate to the same standard of living.
This ends up skewing the intuition of the definition of “upper middle class”. Traditionally, the top quintile means you are upper middle class. By this definition it requires about $87k/yr. This is exactly 50% above the papers definition for a single person. I’m not saying their method is wrong, just that it doesn’t fit with how we traditionally talk about economic classes.
- bumby 6y agoI misread part of the study. The “each” part was for each household, so you’d have to cut those numbers in half for the $163k and $256k statement above