3 ms·
MiSTer is an amazing phenomenon. The MiSTer itself is just an Intel FPGA devkit, which many believe to be sold at a loss (because it's a training tool and not I
by phendrenad2 6y ago
MiSTer is an amazing phenomenon. The MiSTer itself is just an Intel FPGA devkit, which many believe to be sold at a loss (because it's a training tool and not Intel's main source of FPGA revenue). The amazing thing is the aftermarket for addons. There are many possible combinations of addon boards that add RAM with deterministic latency, USB hubs, cooling fans, cases, retro controller ports, etc. All custom-made for this ecosystem.
- tinybear1 6y agoIt is definitely being sold at a loss, the Cyclone V SOC being used costs more than the entire development board.[0] I wonder if Intel will ever take notice due to MiSTer's growing popularity and quit subsidizing the board. [0] https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/intel/5CSEBA6U23I7N/3929193 https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/intel/5CSEBA6U23I... Edit: it was erroneous of me to state the board was being sold at a loss, rather I meant that the board was being definitely being subsidized by companies such as Intel and their partners such as Panasonic. My mistake. I also wasn't meaning to convey that the consumer Digikey pricing was the same as the large volume manufacturers such as Terasic. Rather I meant to demonstrate and agree with the OP on the astounding situation that MiSTer currently exists in, owning to the lack of economic viability for someone to produce a low volume commercial FPGA emulation machine for a niche audience without any subsidization.
- tverbeure 6y agoThere is absolutely no way they’re sold at a loss. Your DigiKey price of $245 proves this, because a factor of 10 is a good starting point as a ratio between volume and one-off DigiKey pricing of any type of complex silicon. A better way to approach this is as follows: what’s the die size of an FPGA like this? What’s the production cost of the die? Then check the historic gross margin percentage of FPGA companies. Xilinx is around 68%, and that includes high-end products which carry the highest markups, unlike this cookie cutter thing. That should give you a good ballpark number. DigiKey charges what they do because nobody else is willing to sell these things in low volume, and they have very high inventory costs.
- andrewcchen 6y agoDigikey pricing is not indicative of actual volume pricing, especially for FPGAs where they are often many times overpriced when buying from distributors. I doubt the board is sold at an loss, probably sold at a small profit, not that's it's really significant for a low volume dev board.
- tverbeure 6y agoThe price of a DE10-Nano is $135 ($115 for academic use.) Anyone who thinks that Terasic sells these at a loss doesn’t have a clue about volume pricing of FPGAs. And as a special Intel partner, there’s little doubt that Terasic has access to this kind of pricing.