4 ms·
I have a librem 5. At first I tried setting it up with a keyboard, mouse & monitor, but it was a little fiddly to get everything usable. I had a USB-C hub fro
by m463 6y ago
I have a librem 5.
At first I tried setting it up with a keyboard, mouse & monitor, but it was a little fiddly to get everything usable.
I had a USB-C hub from a macbook with PD + ethernet + hdmi, but I couldn't get the hdmi display to sync.
So I got another usb-c hub with ethernet + dp (+other ports) and that worked.
amazing: my phone desktop showing up on my 4k monitor!
So, that was pretty cool, but I still had a lot of fiddling to do - like which display the app comes up on, and how to switch things around. Also sometimes the display wasn't recognized when I wanted it do - I think I had to reboot with the display plugged in, because hotplug sometimes didn't work.
(There have been software updates since I tried this - it may be better now).
However, at the same time I ordered the second hub, I also got a $15 USB-C + PD + ethernet dongle.
Turns out that was really what I wanted. Let the phone be a phone, sit there charging and ssh/scp into it from my regular system. I can access the entire filesystem.
All of this really drives things home about Apple.
When the iPhone came out, apple was breaking new ground, so people even accepted web apps, because before they had nothing. And with quality/security, the app store made sense.
But after over a decade you realize that the apple ecosystem is more about control.
Why can't I write my own apps (without asking permission/eula). Why can't I run my own apps without either signing up as a developer and paying, or renew some certificate every 7 days? Why can't I plug all the things into USB and use them?
Apple has mindfully denied a lot of utility for their users. I thought maybe the mac usability would trickle over to iOS, but it seems the iOS lockdown has trickled over to the mac instead.
EDIT: wait. Let me say "Thank You" to the purism folks for doing this. It took a few years, but this phone makes me really really happy. I figure in a year or two it will let normal folks happily run their lives ios/android-free.
- tediousdemise 6y agoSo, effectively—your phone is your computer? This is awesome. This is what general purpose computing was meant to be. Marketing caused us to regress to the fragmented landscape of gimmicky special purpose devices that we have today.
- calvinmorrison 6y agoOn recent droids this works surprisingly well. I have a keyboard in my bag instead of my laptop now.
- nvllsvm 6y agoA shame Google's Pixels don't support wired video output.
- spijdar 6y agoYeah, it's a shame Google never wired up those video-out pins on the SoC. It still rubs me the wrong way that evidently Google could have enabled video-out but chose not to for whatever reason.
- InvertedRhodium 6y agoThe issue of display is the only thing that keeps me dragging a laptop around. I've been keeping an eye on monitor replacement AR glasses but looks like I'll be waiting another decade or so for anything consumer ready.
- fsflover 6y agohttp://nexdock.com/ http://nexdock.com/
- kybernetikos 6y agoI have an ASUS Zenscreen MB16A. It's very portable, has a battery, touchscreen, speakers, input from either micro HDMI or USB C. The only disadvantage is that the battery will only last a few hours unless you have it plugged into usb-c charger, and I haven't worked out a way of charging it and giving it a usb-c signal at the same time yet (so when I'm using it at my desk I use the micro HDMI input).
- LegitShady 6y agoI sort of agree. It wasn't marketing it was the failure of regulators to enforce the same sort of regulations they used against Microsoft to stop apple et al from becoming monstrous entities in the back of policies that stifle innovation and limit choice.
- cbozeman 6y ago> I figure in a year or two it will let normal folks happily run their lives ios/android-free. I hate to be "that guy" - and it seems like I always have to be "that guy" - but this will never allow "normal" folks to happily run their lives iOS / Android free. The reason is because the collection, categorization, and collation of data on smartphone users is what drives the whole thing forward. It's the gas. The petrol. The solar power. The wind turbines. Without apps collecting and using data about their users, everything ends up having to be monetized differently and people have already shown that's not going to happen. You can't even get people to pay a few dollars a month for the single most important "app" on the Internet - email. Sorry, but Librem 5 will never be more than a fun developer's toy. Most people are honestly pretty lazy and the sad simple fact is that they do not want to be challenged at all ever. They want to show up somewhere... bang on their keyboard like a monkey, or swing their hammer like a chimp, or smack their buttons like a macaque, and go home eight hours later, and then in 7-14 days, collect their bananas and eat them while watching Ow! My Balls!, or a slightly more advanced version of it like, American Ninja Warrior. While the rest of nature is in a desperate bid for survival-at-all-costs that is consistently wiping out the slowest and the dumbest, through our struggle, we've managed to regress... we allow the dumbest and the least fit to survive. I know a bunch of wannabe evolutionary biologists here are going to throw around ideas they don't really understand, like, "Fitness doesn't mean being the smartest or the strongest, just the organism most able to reproduce!" No, that's just one single strategy, and not even always an optimal one. This isn't an argument for killing off the dumb and weak, of course. I'm merely pointing out that most people have zero desire to be truly challenged, on anything, ever. That's exactly why they want their Samsung walled Android experience and their Apple walled iOS experience. I wish we lived in a world where everyone spent a few dozen to a few hundred hours learning hard stuff to thereby make their lives permanently easier, but we don't. Most would rather spend a few hours doing relatively monotonous stuff over and over than actually learn something new. OR Maybe I'm just being an old curmudgeon. I guess we'll see.
- danpalmer 6y ago> I wish we lived in a world where everyone spent a few dozen to a few hundred hours learning hard stuff to thereby make their lives permanently easier, but we don't. Most would rather spend a few hours doing relatively monotonous stuff over and over than actually learn something new. I get this, but I'm not sure that using a phone that exposes a full Linux system is the answer here. In fact I think for many people one could make the opposite argument – spend a few hours learning how to use an iPhone and never have to worry about many classes of problems. Yes, many people use iPhones because they don't have the ability to make an informed decision, but many people also have all the skills to make that decision and still choose them. It's all trade-offs, and for some, walled gardens and EULAs are not a problem, and having a camera and (closed source) software that allows better photos of their kids is far more important.