4 ms·
> His Computers Will All Boot Super Fast Seems pretty true for the non-Windows uses cases at least, in my experience (iOS, Android, Linux, macOS).
by gumby 6y ago
> His Computers Will All Boot Super Fast
Seems pretty true for the non-Windows uses cases at least, in my experience (iOS, Android, Linux, macOS).
- cloudking 6y agoChromeOS is probably the fastest (Linux based)
- thomastjeffery 6y agoChromebooks were already that fast at the time he made the prediction, mostly because they were designed to use coreboot instead of the usual bloated uefi/bios. The only reason wee don't see coreboot everywhere is that motherboard manufacturers refuse to adopt or even allow it.
- jeffbee 6y agoYeah, ChromeOS downloads and applies updates unobtrusively and raises a notification to reboot, which takes a few seconds. macOS takes half an hour to update even if you have an M1 and their fancy SSD. Android takes about the same time and their handsets will get scalding hot during the process. ChromeOS is also the fastest of the non-mobile operating systems to wake from sleep. It is up and running and on wifi before I can raise the lid to its normal position.
- rusk 6y agoAndroid in my experience takes aaaaages. By far the biggest boot slouch in modern times.
- papaf 6y agoThat might be hardware related. Android-x86 in a Qemu VM boots in under 3 seconds.
- rusk 6y agoMaybe that’s the case in theory but in practice I have never had a fast booting android device and some of them have been pretty good. Pretty much any other OS is fine. I guess in a virtualised environment you don’t have the same challenges regarding integrating a disparate hardware stack ...
- kelnos 6y agoBooting an Android emulator is a benchmark that only an Android developer would care about, though. It isn't directly comparable to booting real hardware, anyway.
- maxerickson 6y agoI imagine the typical user initiation on Windows is also super fast, just not a cold boot.
- kylec 6y agoFocusing on boot times is weird though, it used to be important when you would boot up your computer in order to use it. Nowadays everything is always sleeping, and can be woken up in an instant to be used, so how long things take to cold boot aren't relevant anymore.
- tokamak-teapot 6y agoI miss the cold boot time of RISC OS on Archimedes hardware: https://youtu.be/oKrEH8U-xOI https://youtu.be/oKrEH8U-xOI
- Narishma 6y agoIsn't that because the OS is in ROM?
- pmyteh 6y agoFor the early versions on Archimedes hardware, yes. Later versions had increasing amounts on disk, which increased the boot time from 'nearly instant' to merely 'fairly quick'. Although recent versions of RISC OS are now entirely softloaded, the increased speed of the Raspberry Pi and other modern hardware platforms has cheerfully reduced boot time again: by modern standards RISC OS is tiny!
- tokamak-teapot 6y agoIt helped at the time, certainly. An SSD in a modern computer is much faster than ROM from back then, though, and instead of an 8Mhz CPU we have 2000+ MHz CPUs.
- MiddleEndian 6y agoNot that I turn my devices off very often, but I'm pretty sure my Windows laptop boots faster than any Android device I've ever had.
- ghaff 6y ago2 seconds was probably an unrealistic goal. Probably more to the point is that I rarely need to reboot a system and coming back from suspend almost always works quickly and reliably. In fact, I'd probably argue that's the more relevant metric at this point.
- tomjen3 6y agoAgreed. And even if the computer booted in 2 seconds, you would still have to start all the programs you had running again. I am super happy that my computer unsleeps quicker than I can move my hand from the finger print sensor to the keyboard, but I also basically never reboot it.
- city41 6y agoAnd I'd also argue Windows update being so bad is an outlier. I now have one Windows machine in my house and I'm astonished updates still take so long and also prevent you from doing anything else while they install. This is one area that Microsoft really lags behind the competition.
- type0 6y ago> This is one area that Microsoft really lags behind the competition. What competition? If you need to run Windows you'll run Windows. Mac and Linux don't compete with them, these are alternative products but not competing ones.