4 ms·
I've encountered it a little bit, and in both cases I left as soon as I realized I wasn't going to make any more headway. But the key is here: > They immediat
by pjc50 6y ago
I've encountered it a little bit, and in both cases I left as soon as I realized I wasn't going to make any more headway.
But the key is here:
> They immediately asked who was giving up this information and wanted to crack down on this perceived insubordination, rather than trying to address the issue
One of the key elements of the "boss" social role is to enforce subordination: people doing what you tell them to do. This is kind of intrinsic to the interpersonal dynamic, and it's quite hard to avoid doing at least some of the time even if you're aware of how it can be a problem.
The problem with people doing what you tell them to do is that what you tell them to do may be wrong or incomplete. You then have two choices:
- admit error. This is uncomfortable.
- increase the effort to subordinate the person so the boss does not lose face.
There are all sorts of examples and case studies of this kind of thing in command situations. Here's it causing a plane crash: https://www.cnbc.com/2014/02/10/asiana-airlines-to-pursue-cockpit-culture-changes-after-us-crash.html https://www.cnbc.com/2014/02/10/asiana-airlines-to-pursue-co...
- coderintherye 6y agoThe boss role does not have to enforce subordination, there's multiple styles of management which encourage self-leadership in terms of what people work on and how they do it. I'm personally a fan of David Marquet's "Leader-Leader" style. But, because so many people expect to be subjugated in their roles it does require some hurdles to get past normal societal expectations and not everyone is a fit for it, some people just want a task list and to be told what to do. I think the world could be a better place if we could effectively help people sort into the companies with the leadership style that best suits their working style.
- whatever_dude 6y ago> so many people expect to be subjugated Was thinking something along the same lines. I work in an environment where a tiny bit of self initiative does very well for one's work and career, and still some people can't get it over their heads. Unless something is very clearly stated somewhere, they won't do it no matter how obvious it is, even people who are trying to get a promotion. I swear sometimes I think people would let the office burn because "yelling fire!" is not of their stated position responsibilities.
- neatze 6y agoThis primarily can be attributed to how people perceive risk and risk aversion mechanisms, don't think this would be false to assume it also relates to responsibility. Self initiative people willing to take more risk and thus responsibility if things don't work out, where not self initiative people if things don't work out, take substantially less responsibility by default.
- mch82 6y agoI have explicitly instructed my team to let me know if I ask them to do something stupid so we can avoid the mistake. I was so excited the first time someone spoke up to alert me that I was overlooking a better option & made sure to celebrate the alert in order to keep the transparency going. There may be teams where this direct approach wouldn’t work out, but so far it’s seemed to help.
- neatze 6y agoTo very large degree Boss/Management role is to support (indirect control) allocation of human capital resources to tasks in relation to objectives with minimal inefficiencies such as; conflicts, overlap in tasks, miscoordination. I would argue there is virtually no justification to manage people by means direct control, virtually for any team/group sizes.
- pjc50 6y agoThat's the organizational role. The interpersonal, social one is often a lot more primitive and has nothing to do with capital or resources.
- neatze 6y agoSorry, for being so direct, but are we still talking about small business/enterprise organization or family and friends ? > has nothing to do with capital or resources. Is most confusing point for me. In general, if you meant enforcing compliance, I would have different response, but you clearly did not mean that in your original post.
- pjc50 6y agoIn any organisation, although it's more likely to be bad in small ones. I'm talking about the difference between the formal, process-related aspects of management and the social/anthropological/dominance aspects. All the stuff that matters once voices get raised and feelings get high. To tie this back to the original post: why is there information that subordinates have that would potentially improve the business, that they want to give to their seniors, but they don't? It's because that information is uncomfortable. Also, all the stuff in the original article below "Incredible amounts of harassment of any kind". Why do business deals get done at strip clubs in the first place? It's not in the company's interest, it happens because those involved have enough power to use company resources for their own purposes and enjoy all the little displays of dominance involved in such an outing.
- 6y ago