4 ms·
> Profit apportionment. If 20% of your revenue comes from a particular state or country, that jurisdiction gets to tax 20% of your profit. There's already a lo
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> Profit apportionment. If 20% of your revenue comes from a particular state or country, that jurisdiction gets to tax 20% of your profit.
There's already a local tax on revenue. Sales tax.
- Retric 6y agoSales tax isn’t collected on components of products. So an apple farm sells apples to a factory without any sales tax etc. Taxing on point of sale is very useful if you want to capture externalities, but it’s got minimal effect on the supply chain.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoHow is that relevant here? The notional problem consists of Apple Inc. selling an iPhone and then paying a royalty on the trade dress to Delawapple Inc. There is no supply chain involved, so it doesn't matter if the supply chain is unaffected. The proposal above is that California should get to assess taxes against Apple based on Apple's revenue from California. And they do. That's what a sales tax is.
- gamblor956 6y agoAs discussed in other comments, the notional problem doesn't actually exist. The article was simply wrong on the Delaware Loophole in general; it still works in a handful of small states but it hasn't worked in any respectably sized state for longer than most people on HN have been alive. Apple wouldn't get a California deduction for its "payment" of a "royalty" to Delawapple for an iPhone sold in California. It would get assessed a tax on the income it makes selling the iPhone to a buyer. Note also: sales tax is a tax owed by the buyer of a good, not the seller. It is simply collected by the seller because it is more efficient for the seller to handle sales tax remittances than for each of their customers to do so. It's less overall work, it's easier to audit, and the seller can simply send the collected amounts in with their other periodic tax payments.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Note also: sales tax is a tax owed by the buyer of a good, not the seller. There is not even a theoretical difference between these two ideas.
- Retric 6y agoMany states exclude 501 charities from paying sales tax which makes a tangible difference, and would be impossible if the seller paid the tax.
- ac29 6y agoSales tax is not a tax on revenue, its a tax on purchases (paid by the purchaser). Perhaps you are saying business taxes should be non-existent, but in most places they do exist. Also, dont confuse revenue and profit. While some locales do have a gross receipts tax, taxing profits is much more common. This, in theory, incentivizes companies to pay out their revenues in the form of wages, R&D, building things, etc.