3 ms·
What's "no technology", because ancient rome was full of giant wealth gaps. Maybe if you mean hunter-gatherer societies, but i don't really know enough about th
by bawolff 6y ago
What's "no technology", because ancient rome was full of giant wealth gaps. Maybe if you mean hunter-gatherer societies, but i don't really know enough about them to comment.
- donw 6y agoRome was an incredibly advanced society with a great deal of technology, though.
- anoncake 6y agoNot compared to today. If technology and wealth gap were linked, ancient Rome would have been much more equal than our society.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> What's "no technology", A poor, non-existing fanciful hypothetical argument that cannot stand on it's own, but is made to illustrate an ill-convinced point: because since the advent of anatomical Humans (~200k-300k) we see evidence of Man was using clubs or spears fashioned from wood, or arrowheads with the art in caves to go with it. All of which fall under technology of some sort. In short, its a poorly reasoned hypothetical to support one's own biases and perhaps disdain for tech and the inherent inequality that follows from those who benefit from it.
- indigo945 6y agoThis is correct. More generally, there is absolutely no evidence that wealthier people do, on average, "leverage" technologies better. Ancient Rome is one example because while advanced technology existed, the wealthiest people were land owners taking in the profits of slave labor, not the architects and inventors who built temples and refined concrete. Of course, the same is true for modern society. Even so-called "tech entrepreneurs" like Elon Musk do much better at seeking profits than "leveraging technologies" -- as paying people to develop technologies isn't the same thing as leveraging them for increasing the productivity of oneself, at all. However, of course, the argument is hardly surprising. After all, much of the ideology of modern capitalism rests on the ideal of the Iron Man, the genius inventor who, by his smartness (and benevolent white masculinity) embodies the excuse for the exploitation of the Earth's natural resources, for the creeping destruction of our democracy and the huge disparities in wealth and power that go along with it. You just have to believe this is real, otherwise all you ever learned from Coca Cola advertising would be wrong, at that is too painful to admit.
- donw 6y ago> The wealthiest [Romans] were land owners taking in the profits of slave labor Not exactly. Crassus amassed his fortune first through conquest, and then through real estate speculation. Caesar and Pompey's fortunes were a mixture of family wealth and the spoils of war. There was certainly a class of wealthy Romans that derived their wealth -- and Rome's food supply! -- from land worked by slaves (mostly captured in war and brought in from all over Europe). But the wealthiest were, by far, the political-military ruling class, who accrued their wealth through bribes and conquest.
- indigo945 6y agoI mean, you are right, but this is nitpicking and doesn't really relate to my argument. Exploiting slaves and robbing Gallia aren't that far apart, as far as technological sophistication goes.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoHow do you think conquest made someone wealthy? It was through gaining ownership of land and by capturing slaves.
- simonsarris 6y agoAndrew Carnegie noted that the richest men in 1850's America were barely rich by the standards of the 1890, because of the technological changes and industries created, which minted huge fortunes. Similar huge fortunes are made any time more technology breaks out and scales better. That's what he means.
- stretchwithme 6y agoBeing able to force other people to do things is a way of multiplying your efforts. And we still HIRE people and delegate tasks to them. And, as Melting_Harps pointed out, weapons are a technology. And so is communication and methods of organizing a larger society. Storing grain is a technology too. Even agriculture is a technology. But now we have many more ways to do this. If I write an app and millions install and use it, I am multiplying the amount of work I can get done for people and what they are willing to pay for it. Much better for them than threatening them with my army. Especially since I have been unable to find it. :-)