6 ms·
Suppose, for the sake of argument, that you are right to the extreme: Covid kills a non-negligible fraction of people 65 and up and has zero mortality or long t
by amluto 6y ago
Suppose, for the sake of argument, that you are right to the extreme: Covid kills a non-negligible fraction of people 65 and up and has zero mortality or long term consequences for people under 65. [0] Even if this were true, doing nothing to control the spread among under-65-year-olds would result in absolutely enormous numbers of cases over a fairly short period of time. Do you really expect that the large majority of people over 65 could be protected effectively when the considerable majority of under-65 people to whom they are exposed (caregivers, food providers, relatives, etc) get covid?
I do not believe that most of the world has responded in a particularly useful way to covid, but I do believe that masks are quite effective (especially N95 or comparable masks) at reducing the spread of covid in indoor spaces. So yes, mask mandates, at least indoors, make quite a lot of sense.
The school closure issue is harder. There seems to be surprisingly little data on the degree to which covid spreads among children compared to adults and the degree to which covid spreads from children to adults. But most schools consist of students indoors, in a poorly ventilated space, often crowded, talking, for hours a day. Read the article: this is prime covid-spreading conditions. Perhaps schools could have been allowed to remain open to the extent that they could move outdoors or drastically improve ventilation, but doing nothing seems likely to have been a very bad idea.
[0] This is not actually the case, obviously.
- moron4hire 6y agoTo me, in the absence of data, we should default to using best-guess models and not just throw up our hands and say "whatever, nobody knows for sure, just keep on keepin' on". Anyone who has children knows that pretty much any disease rips through schools. If COVID-19 were to eventually be proven to not transmit between children in meaningful numbers, it'd be a huge irregularity. But so many people treat this "no proof of transmission" situation as "proof of no transmission".
- henrikschroder 6y ago> Anyone who has children knows that pretty much any disease rips through schools. If COVID-19 were to eventually be proven to not transmit between children in meaningful numbers If? We already know that it doesn't. Yes, other viruses rip through schools rapidly, but this virus simply doesn't. Your gut feeling is wrong. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-briefs/transmission_k_12_schools.html#covid-19-children-adolescents https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-br... "Younger children (<10 years of age) may be less likely to be infected than adolescents. This possibility is supported by contact tracing studies; test positivity data from children, adolescents, and adults; and population screening studies using seroprevalence data. Susceptibility to SARS-CoV-2 infection and the proportion among those infected experiencing symptoms both generally increase with age."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- totony 6y ago>Even if this were true, doing nothing to control the spread among under-65-year-olds would result in absolutely enormous numbers of cases over a fairly short period of time. I don't think this is something you can claim without backing. I fail to see significant logic/empirical observations that make it seem futile to you that stopping the spread to a subset of the population is significantly harder than for the whole population. >Do you really expect that the large majority of people over 65 could be protected effectively when the considerable majority of under-65 people to whom they are exposed (caregivers, food providers, relatives, etc) get covid? Exposing the not-at-risk population would likely increase the short-term risk (all measures constant) but decrease the long-term risk to people over 65. Having a smaller population to focus on protecting would likely make their protection easier. Even if you were right in that you would have more casualties from selective locking down (which I am unconvinced), would the increased death toil justify the freedom being messed with for the whole population?
- benlivengood 6y agoAsymptomatic spreaders are the biggest risk to vulnerable populations and there wasn't a way to detect that before the pcr tests, nor a foolproof way (even now) to test everyone at-risk populations might come in contact with. A substantial risk of passing a deadly virus on to vulnerable people is not a freedom, it's negligence.
- totony 6y ago>A substantial risk of passing a deadly virus on to vulnerable people is not a freedom, it's negligence. Stay-at-home orders/curfews are affronts to freedom. Derailing this to imply wanting to go outside at all is negligence is disingenuous. Preventing people from seeing other people over long period of times is known to be psychologically bad for human (and is a form of torture, see [1]. Although it is different in some ways, it seems clear its not good for the population well-being). >nor a foolproof way (even now) to test everyone at-risk populations might come in contact with. Don't let perfection hinder practicality. Keeping at-risk population away from infected people at a good rate is very feasible. It doesn't have to be foolproof (nor is it right now). It does not seem either harder or worse than what we are doing right now. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solitary_confinement#Torture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solitary_confinement#Torture
- aeternum 6y agoIt's always hard to argue that we should do less when it comes to saving lives, but perhaps a better way to look is whether we're focused on the right thing. In 2019, heart disease killed 18.6 million people whereas Covid has taken 2.9 million lives. Heart disease is also a major factor in severe Covid cases. Couldn't we save more lives if we took all this governmental effort that we are putting towards tiered business closures and mask mandates and instead focused it on national, maybe even mandatory exercise programs? On average, people were about 6x more likely to die of heart disease than covid over this last year, yet we take comparatively little if any action.
- galaxyLogic 6y ago> people were about 6x more likely to die of heart disease than covid Could you add a link to where you get those numbers from. What the link below says is that "Covid-19 is the Number One Cause of Death in the U.S. in Early 2021". If Covid-19 is the number one cause of death, how could heart-disease be 6x more likely cause of death? https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/brief/covid-19-is-the-number-one-cause-of-death-in-the-u-s-in-early-2021/ https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/brief/covid-19-is-the-nu...
- totony 6y agoTake care when interpreting this kind of data. Even if it were true that Covid-19 is the number one cause of death for 2020, you can make a strong case that this number contains a significant number of unhealthy people which would have died from heart disease & al in the near future. This means that covid effectively "steals" death from a category in the short term. Which would mean that heart disease is still a bigger long term/overall issue than Covid. Plus this doesn't take into account the reporting bias that seems to have been (be?) prevalent in 2019. (Although it seems heart disease was still bigger than covid for 2020 [1] if compared to 2019 [2] in the us) [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=number+of+death+covid+2020+us https://www.google.com/search?q=number+of+death+covid+2020+u... - 561k covid [2] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm - 659k heart disease
- alexashka 6y agoOld people die. Sorry, the world is made in a way where old people die and young people live. If you don't like it - take it up with the way the universe works. I don't know when it's been decided that we're going to prevent young people from living, so that people who are going to die soon anyway get a few more years. I mean, the entire system is made up of exploiting young people so that old rich scum get richer but uh, how long can this go on? Young people don't even have children anymore, while the profits of old rich scum are record high. This trend obviously can't continue so I'm waiting for a voice of reason to say 'enough of this shit already, you're not going to live forever and we're not going to walk on egg-shells for the rest of our lives to appease your irrational fear of death'. Oh, one more thing - if you give a shit about people not dying of viruses world-wide - try not letting virus carrying things travel world-wide because it's 'fun'. I mean, what kind of games are we playing here? This is a self inflicted wound by stupid rich people that everyone else now has to pay for.
- AVoiceOfReason 6y agoEnough of this shit already, you're not going to live forever and we're not going to walk on egg-shells for the rest of our lives to appease your irrational fear of death.
- neilwilson 6y ago" I do believe that masks are quite effective (especially N95 or comparable masks) at reducing the spread of covid in indoor spaces." Why do you believe it rather than know it from solid science? The problem is that the whole mask thing has dubious impact, much like Vitamin D, or washing hands and the rest, but has become a symbol of political allegiance, not medical impact. What was predicted to happen in Texas hasn't happened. There has been absolutely no evidence anywhere of children in schools being vectors for transmission. They suffer very little sickness from the disease and don't seem to spread the virus until they start showing actual symptoms - both of which directly contradict the prevailing narrative. Yet these glaring anomalies seem to be dismissed by the prevailing belief. Even simply mentioning them has become verboten as the response to this post will probably show. I don't believe anybody has looked into whether different types of people from different ages 'leak' the virus differently. That would go some way to explain the difference between the Diamond Princess experience (full of older people), and schools (full of younger people). We know very little and humility in the face of that is called for. What we're doing now is going to look foolish in the future once we know more.
- zzleeper 6y agoAre you serious? Even if you don't know/believe an actual paper, you can always look at first principles: 1) If N95 masks didn't work, all doctors and nurses in ICUs treating covid patients would get sick quite quickly. But that didn't, and in fact they got sick at a similar rate to other doctors (this is from Peru where they had lots and lots of covid) 2) These masks literally stop the virus from passing into your respiratory system. So why would you be surprised if they prevent disease transmission?
- neilwilson 6y ago"all doctors and nurses in ICUs treating covid patients would get sick quite quickly." But that's doctors and nurses in a highly controlled environment where we know there is an awful lot of virus particles around. That controlled environment doesn't occur elsewhere, so you are comparing apples and pears. Leakage round the side, not wearing the masks fully, not changing often enough, etc. all apply in the field not the hospital, and even then the network effects can outstrip the filtering effect. Concentrations matter - as it does with radiation where high radiation areas damage the body and then when it drops below a certain level there is little impact at all. Extrapolating from hospital to elsewhere is problematic and simply not supported by the evidence. " These masks literally stop the virus from passing into your respiratory system." Again in controlled environments, not in the field where that level of protection isn't available nor is it managed, changed or worn properly in all cases. The reality on the ground shows that. There is no detectable effect outside really controlled environments without a high degree of curve fitting and bias. Texas has not exploded has it. The downvotes say it all. People no longer wants to discuss rationally the possibility that they may be mistaken. It has become a religious crusade to do with identity. The motto of the Royal Society is "Nullus in Verba" - take nobody's word for it. The essence of science is to question, not censor. We appear to have forgotten that.
- NoblePublius 6y agoI will always, always value the right of children to go to school and the right of Americans to run a small business over the completely hypothetical notion that a novel corona virus has intense long term side effects. Schools are open in Florida and the kids are fine. There have been a billion, probably two billion, infections so far and near zero evidence of widespread long term effects. If one percent are “long haulers” there should be 10-20 million of them. Where are they? What there is indisputable evidence of is a dramatic increase in drug overdoses, suicides, stroke and heart attack deaths at home (which are callously and cravenly classified as excess mortality due to Covid). I am supposed to chant BLACK LIVES MATTER in the street when police kill 250 black people/year but am supposed to clap and cheer when the Teachers Unions demand that 40 million Children of Color are locked at home with no equipment for distance learning. Please stop pretending that a disease with 99.95% survival rate (99.999% under age 50) justifies ten trillion dollars of self imposed economic disaster. Please stop telling me I need to cover my face when walking my dog outside, Dr Biden. The threat of this virus has been drastically exaggerated to influence politics, undermine property rights, bail out failing corporations, and enrich a select few.
- amluto 6y ago> If one percent are “long haulers” there should be 10-20 million of them. Where are they? What there is indisputable evidence of is a dramatic increase in drug overdoses, suicides, stroke and heart attack deaths at home (which are callously and cravenly classified as excess mortality due to Covid). I would love for you to be right. Sadly, if you actually try to look up the incidence of long covid (or post covid syndrome, etc), you will find estimates ranging from 5-25% incidence. Optimistically divide by five (I’m giving you the benefit of the doubt here) if you want to estimate the incidence among total infections instead of symptomatic infections. Divide by 10 if you think that 90% of patients will recover fully and quickly enough that you should discount them. You’re left with 0.1% to 0.5%. You appear to be a couple of orders of magnitude off in your calculation.