4 ms·
I remember almost exactly the same argument being made in 2009 about Android on phones. Here's how it unfolded chronologically then: 1) "no one can complete w
by nl 15y ago
I remember almost exactly the same argument being made in 2009 about Android on phones.
Here's how it unfolded chronologically then:
1) "no one can complete with Apple because of the quality of design"
2) "no one can compete with Apple, only geeks buy Android phones"
3) "no one can compete with Apple, except if you are a geek or want a phone on a non AT&T network"
4) "no one can compete with Apple, except if you want a non AT&T phone or want a low end handset"
5) "Ok, Android is outselling Apple, but Apple is more profitable"
So... why, exactly will the tablet market be different?
- Pewpewarrows 15y agoIt's sad how much a certain subset of HN users have the memory of a goldfish when it comes to this sort of history of technology. Back when they just had OSX, market-share meant nothing. It was all about quality. When Android released and iPhone was dominating the smartphone sector? Market-share was all you'd hear about. When Android surpassed iPhone in market-share? It's all about the size of the App Store, man. Android Market set to outnumber the App Store? Doesn't matter, look at how much more money Apple's paid to its developers! (Let's conveniently ignore the fact that the App Store's been around about twice as long). Now we get the see the same arguments happen all over again for the tablet market. I, for one, will enjoy watching it repeat itself with my bowl of popcorn.
- nl 15y agoOh yeah, I forgot about the size-of-appstore arguments. Edit: So how am I supposed to interprete the downvotes? Is it just a vote against me being dumb enough to forget it? That the argument doesn't exist? Please explain!
- Stormbringer 15y agoI downvote meta-discussions about downvotes on general principles
- Stormbringer 15y agoGruber is a prime example of this. Exactly as you describe, when Macs didn't have market share it was all about how market share didn't matter. And, to be honest, he made a pretty compelling argument. But every time Apple jumped up a rank in US or global sales there was a gleefulness and gloating aspect to the posts that would report it. When rumours of the iPhone was leaked there was enormous sledging of Apple. People literally made mocking posts about how ridiculous a one button phone would be. Apple and their one button phone were the laughing stock of tech punditry. For months people wrote about what idiots Apple and their fanboys were. Then Apple demoed the iPhone, and everybody suddenly realised that the "drooling idiot fanboys" were right after all. So yes, guys like Gruber are being hypocritical with their banner waving "we're number one" stuff. but they took so much crap for so long, that to resist that urge to thumb your nose and do the "nyah nyah I told you so" thing would require super-human self-control. ---- In market share there is almost never a complete victory. Even Microsoft almost but not quite had a complete victory in the OS wars. They could have killed off Apple, but didn't. Now, 10-15 years later, if you looked at profitability or the market cap you'd be forgiven for thinking that Apple had won that war. But if you look at market share you'd still think that Apple had one foot in the grave. The problem is that all these one dimensional views are (surprise!) myopic. We love to make straight-up comparisons of Apple and Microsoft - but Apple is predominantly a hardware/entertainment company and Microsoft is predominantly a software/business company. It's like trying to compare an insurance company with a supermarket (which is possible, but it requires hard work and patient analysis, neither of which pundits are generally blessed with an abundance of). Would we compare Microsoft and Dell, and say that Microsoft had "beaten" Dell? No? Why not? After all, there are people who hold the view that Microsoft encouraged and pushed the commoditisation of PC hardware, which meant that the hardware manufacturer's profitability kept getting chipped [sic] away at. Fanboy gladiatorial aspirations aside, you could probably make a better argument about Microsoft being at war with its hardware partners (atn: Nokia -> Microsoft is not your friend) like HP and Dell than it being at war with Apple.
- tres 15y ago> So... why, exactly will the tablet market be different? I think the author states a good reason -- that a tablet device is more of a luxury item that appeals to people who want to geek out with it; it makes this a whole different context. If Honeycomb devices can compete against iOS, then so much the better for everyone (even Apple); however, there are significantly different market segments that will be drawn to a device that is free-with-subscription and a market willing to pay $500+ to play. Institutional adoption of Honeycomb based devices has big potential to jumpstart Android on tablets (i.e. schools buying devices), but it's pretty safe to say the consumer marketplace is locked up. Apple can compete on price in the tablet marketplace, so until there's somebody willing to subsidize the tablet -- like the phones are -- there's really no choice.
- nl 15y agoIs there any actual evidence that tablets are a luxury item, that doesn't equally apply to the iPhone? Here in Australia the number 2 carrier recently did a sale on their self-branded version of the ZTE V9 tablet (7", Android 2.2, surprisingly good resisitive touch screen: http://www.zte.com.au/optus/V9.htm http://www.zte.com.au/optus/V9.htm) for $99 including 3GB of pre-paid data. It sold out country-wide in less than a day. The ZTE V9 is no iPad, but the speed it sold (in non-trivial numbers) indicates significant demand, at the right price. Some manufactures are willing to meet that price. Coincidentally, the same thing happened with the 7" Samsung Tablet. Samsung dropped the price here to under $300, and suddenly you can no longer buy it because everytime stock comes in it sells out immediately. I don't think that's the market behavior for a luxury good.
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoMy theory is that tablets are "luxury" in the sense that if you already own a smartphone or laptop/netbook then you've already covered those bases to some degree. A tablet might do certain things better, but maybe not enough better for you to buy one at a given price. Just like you might find it hard to justify a point'n'shoot camera, an iPod, or a Nintendo DS if you already have an iPhone that can already do those things, even if not quite as well. However, if the price drops even further, then it can become something to buy and leave lying around the house for occasional use, or to try out on a whim. I'm not sure there's a big market for high-end tablets, just as I think high-end point'n'shoots, iPods, and portable games machines might face a shrinking market in future.