4 ms·
Using an adblocker is like stealing candy from the store... They can handle some theft, but if literally everyone stole their candy, the store would close down
by londons_explore 6y ago
Using an adblocker is like stealing candy from the store...
They can handle some theft, but if literally everyone stole their candy, the store would close down and nobody can have candy.
- goalieca 6y agoIt’s been said many times, but if the business model is advertising then you’re the product.. not the quality journalism or content. They’ll focus on generating content to increase engagement instead of perfecting what you think it is they are supposed to deliver. Perhaps it is time for an advertising model to die out as the default.
- cortesoft 6y agoOk, then don’t patronize sites supported by ads.
- Nursie 6y agoThis is why I’m more than happy when sites say “adblocker detected, please disable or leave”. I will not render your ads. I’d be happy to put that in the first http request to your site. If that means no site for me, then quite honestly 90% of my browsing is a waste of time anyway.
- simias 6y agoOr they'll move on to a more sustainable business model that doesn't involve selling their user's privacy?
- jshen 6y agoA business model that will exclude the poor.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoLets not pretend that ads help people with less money. Ads are designed to manipulate people into buying things they don't need. They encourage people to believe their self worth is linked to the things they own. That a persons status in society is somehow associated with how much money they have to spend.
- rewq4321 6y ago> Lets not pretend that ads help people with less money. Who's pretending? Ads naturally and quite effectively price-discriminate, and so they do make internet content cheaper for people with less money. You may have problems with excessive consumption, but many people in developing countries do not. They desperately need the free content (educational, informative, and otherwise) that the current internet model provides them.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoThere are much better options to provide people with educational, informative and entertaining content. Well funded public broadcasters like Australia ABC provide news and entertainment content free. (both text and video) Well funded public libraries can provide a wide range of alternate content.
- google234123 6y agoYeah, let's pretend libraries have equivalent content to the free internet!
- account42 6y agoLet's pretend that most creators of free content on the internet are compensated by ads.
- jshen 6y agoMy family is made up of poor immigrants, many of whom are back in their home country. Free communication systems are a godsend for them. While I love libraries and public broadcasting, I learned to code as a poor kid through library books, they are not the full solution and they never provided free, instant, and any time international communication for people.
- rapnie 6y agoI still watch traditional TV. Whenever commercials start I zap to another channel immediately. Would I mind if these commercial channels disappeared? Probably not.
- HeckFeck 6y agoI'm not stealing anything by instructing my computer not to run code against my consent. No one is entitled to my CPU time. Least of all are advertisers. Also, the store isn't freakishly stalking me and noting down all my habits whilst sharing what it has collected with its friends, or indeed anyone who will buy the data. Besides, candy is impossible to replicate in the same way that data is. Theft of physical objects is a materially different act from advert blocking and avoidance. I'm not obligated to view adverts in every public space because they fund the local government. I'm not denied access to the cinema because I arrive 10 minutes after the start time to avoid the adverts. Or back in the day when I taped TV shows and fast-forwarded the adverts, had I a responsibility to view them? They're useless noise that contribute no value to anyone beyond whoever pays for them, and therefore I find it a moral responsibility to limit my exposure to them and restrain the harm they do to others. And curiously, I am much more content and much less impulsive in my spending habits since I installed uBlock.
- nitrogen 6y agoAlso, the store isn't freakishly stalking me and noting down all my habits whilst sharing what it has collected with its friends, or indeed anyone who will buy the data. Many retail stores do, actually, through wireless tracking, cameras, and/or purchase history. They will buy and sell consumer data through the likes of Acxiom. It would be great to have a ublock equivalent for the physical world.
- leephillips 6y agoThere is: paying with cash, not using loyalty cards, and refusing to supply zip codes, phone numbers, and whatever else they rudely ask for get you 92% of the way there. For the rest, you can wear a Groucho mask while in the store. But that only works if Groucho masks become popular.
- jeffgreco 6y agoI would respect the Adblock crowd more if they didn’t run around describing their actions as brave or “morally responsible.” It’s ok to admit that you’re taking something without return!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- colonwqbang 6y agoUsing an ablocker is more like going to church wearing earplugs.
- hhvn 6y agoUsing an adblocker is more like walking down the street with earplugs that block out a preacher you didn't want to listen to.
- google234123 6y agoA privately owned and maintained street.
- darepublic 6y agoYeah you're just there for the dating not for the sermonizing
- sennight 6y agoLook up the legal definition of "theft". In your analogy the candy would be the user's privacy and attention, which the adblocker denies the store use of. It is only theft if the store owns the user's privacy and attention. Are you so owned?
- 13415 6y agoOn the contrary, the websites who display ads steal screen space on my machine without paying me for it, some of them even steal computing time by running unauthorized scripts.
- lxgr 6y agoBy the same argument you are stealing the website‘s bandwidth by visiting it without clicking on the ads. These reductionist approaches don‘t really help with understanding ads (and communication in general).
- 13415 6y agoI was kidding, of course. Neither running an ad blocker nor running a website that runs script is stealing anything. However, I do run an ad blocker and I'm completely fine if every company that relies on ads for income goes out of business. In fact, I'd appreciate it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- argvargc 6y agoNo. If advertising became impossible, vendors seeking to compete would be forced to make products good enough to be enthusiastically-shared, word-of-mouth, and everything in the world would be significantly better than it is.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoWell then stop tracking me around the internet and then we'll talk. Ads used to just be 1 direction. Give up the feedback path and I'll be fine as long as I don't get 5 pop ups blocking the article I'm trying to read and THEN fingerprint me and follow me to the next website.
- betterunix2 6y agoThat is a pretty poor argument. There has never been any guarantee that ads will be rendered, and users rapidly learn to ignore areas of the screen where ads typically appear (I have seen user studies to this effect). "Reader mode" will basically prevent ads from being rendered, unless the ads are purely text and are inlined with the main text of the page. Calling ad blockers "theft" is as ridiculous as calling ads themselves "theft" -- after all, the ad companies are using a large fraction of the bandwidth users paid for, and the CPU cycles and electricity on their computers, without having been asked to do so and without having asked permission. If websites really find that ad blockers are killing their revenue, they will switch to a paywall model, and maybe micropayments will finally happen (or perhaps a service that allows users to subscribe to large numbers of websites at a time). Whether or not that is a good thing depends on who you ask.
- gsich 6y agoNo.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoI used to hold this view, and I argued that exchanging ad impressions for web content was some sort of social contract. I think this would be defensible if not for the massive privacy violations, and the fact that Google and Facebook continually alter the deal, and pay politicians to ensure we have no seat at the table to negotiate.