3 ms·
The modern meaning of "gatekeeping" is when you call anything that people buy shit, and you give a reason. The only appropriate long-form emotion is breathless
by pessimizer 6y ago
The modern meaning of "gatekeeping" is when you call anything that people buy shit, and you give a reason. The only appropriate long-form emotion is breathless enthusiasm. Dislike must be exclusively expressed in tweet-length insults calling the fans of a thing names.
Saying why anything is better than anything else is violence. Withholding your approval for a reason makes you basically a cop. If you give a reason why you hate something everyone else likes, you're basically saying everyone is stupid but you. That makes you a "bully."
Imagine being accused of somehow oppressing one of the most successful (and dead) people in a field for venturing that their mass appeal might be due to their mass appeal. Imagine that in a thread about a poet writing for a greeting card company.
-----
edit: this is why downvotes for real disagreement will always be good.
If someone makes a bad argument for why something is bad, you should usually downvote them for the quality of their argument and move on. Exceptions are if someone states a falsehood as a fact, maybe leave a note and a reference to correct the falsehood so it doesn't continue to circulate. Or if you find yourself having to argue extensively to disagree, you are involved in a productive discussion and you shouldn't downvote anything that leads to productive discussion.
But never argue against argumentation, reason against reason, or argue that the act of distinguishing between things at all makes one a bad person. Just downvote and move on.