3 ms·
>There is enough evidence here to make a strong case against alcohol on a number of grounds (which Nutt himself does not quite do). Alcohol is a drain on econo
by Barrin92 6y ago
>There is enough evidence here to make a strong case against alcohol on a number of grounds (which Nutt himself does not quite do).
Alcohol is a drain on economic growth, damaging our productivity and forcing us to spend money on healthcare that could be used elsewhere. The CDC estimated the cost of hangovers to the American economy as $249bn in 2010. The Institute of Alcohol Studies estimates a cost of £1.4bn a year for British productivity.
And therein lies the core argument of the entire piece. Good old fashioned Anglo capitalist puritanism. Don't have fun that could be harmful or dangerous, don't have any pleasure, optimize your life for GDP and close your eyes and think of England.
I seriously wonder why people who argue along these lines and apparently write an entire book on the dangers of alcohol don't just skip that part and go to the actually interesting question and ask themselves why people still drink or do any other drug, because we all know that it's dangerous and harmful etc. But drugs are also a part of our culture, of our social life, they can be a source for creativity or just for pleasure.
There's another interesting little bit in the piece
>"Left unaddressed is why we think that alcohol is necessary to any of those (good and often great) rituals. It’s not. I don’t see why you can’t get most of those social benefits anyway."
I seriously wonder how long you have to hit people on the head with Tyler Cowen books until they actually start to believe this stuff. A ritual is a sacred, integrated activity. It's not some autistic utilitarian thing where you can rip a part out and 'get the social benefits'. You take one part out, the entire thing falls apart. But I don't think people who think like this even have any religious or aesthetic appreciation any more to understand this.
- nottorp 6y ago> Alcohol is a drain on economic growth, damaging our productivity and forcing us to spend money on healthcare that could be used elsewhere. The CDC estimated the cost of hangovers to the American economy as $249bn in 2010. The Institute of Alcohol Studies estimates a cost of £1.4bn a year for British productivity. So? You live to work? Incidentally, it's not hard to learn how to drink all night without having a hangover the next day. Look at tonics or water your wine. Easy peasy.