4 ms·
The exception to this rule is a "bona fide purchaser for value without notice". If someone has no reason to believe that property is stolen and buys it, then it
by jacques_chester 15y ago
The exception to this rule is a "bona fide purchaser for value without notice". If someone has no reason to believe that property is stolen and buys it, then it's their property now. So sorry.
I'm still confused about whether or not bitcoin transactions are traceable. If they have deniability, it might be impossible to prove/disprove that you knew the goods were stolen.
Of course, I am neither a lawyer nor a crypto specialist and this isn't legal advice.
(In particular, the rules vary depending on whether the property is realty, on whether you have a Torrens system, whether you have fused equity and what your local courts and legislatures have decided).
- vrotaru 15y agoWithdrawls from MtGox are traceable. It just a payment to an address which has to be known in order to make that payment. So, unless they (MtGox) have lost that address too..
- jacques_chester 15y agoOK. That suggests that the original owners would be within their rights to demand a return of the coins. (IANAL, TINLA).
- Tichy 15y agoUh, is that really so? So I can steal whatever I want, as long as I can sell it off fast enough? Say I am 99 years old and have only one week left to live. What if I go on a car stealing spree and steal Porsche cars for my extended family. Then I sell it to them for a symbolic 1 cent each, claiming that I have collected them over my lifetime and now want my family to benefit.
- jacques_chester 15y agoYou've misread me. You, the thief, are still on the hook for your crime. The buyer, if they really are a bona fide purchaser for value without notice, is not. Your family would probably not meet the test, as this would be the first time they've heard of the Porsches. (IANAL, TINLA)
- Tichy 15y agoYes, what I mean is that if I was 99, I wouldn't care much about being punished for being a thief. I could therefore make a lot of people happy. If not my family, then maybe I could go Robin Hood, steal from the rich and sell cheaply to the poor. I can't imagine that it works that way. I can believe that as a buyer of stolen good without knowing they were stolen, you won't be punished. But you will still have to return the stuff. I am not a lawyer either, though. If it works as you describe, let's found a guild of 99 year old Robin Hoods...
- jacques_chester 15y ago> If not my family, then maybe I could go Robin Hood, steal from the rich and sell cheaply to the poor. Note "for value". If the price is unrealistically cheap, the courts can point out that the buyer should have been suspicious. > I can't imagine that it works that way. I can believe that as a buyer of stolen good without knowing they were stolen, you won't be punished. But you will still have to return the stuff. You don't have to return it, it's yours now. The point is that the bona fide purchaser is not a criminal and acted in good faith. If, however, there is the slightest whiff of a hint of a suspicion, those bona fides collapse and title reverts to the original owner. It is harder to prove bona fides than you might think. Got a great price? Not for value, test fails. Knew the seller? Not bona fides, test fails. Bought it from someone who has no history of selling those items? Possible notice, test fails. And so on. Look, here's the thing. Lawyers and judges have been working on this system (the common law) for nearly a thousand years. For day-to-day stuff like property, the loopholes are well and truly closed and have been for hundreds of years. That I was an inadequate law student and now am an inadequate explainer does not change the fact that the common law is pretty damn adequate at providing sensible legal protection for almost all imaginable transactions. (IANAL, TINLA)
- Tichy 15y agoAnother question: what happens if somebody steals my Porsche and sells it to somebody else, but I still have a set of car keys. One day I notice my Porsche parked on the curb, use my keys to enter it and drive away? Is it then a Schrödinger-Porsche that belongs to both me and the person who bought it off the thief? What if I never even noticed it was stolen? In fact, as the thief, why even bother with stealing? Why not just sell, say, houses on ebay that don't belong to me?
- gte910h 15y agoThey're not paying enough so no. But in most of the US, that scheme doesn't apply.
- wmf 15y agoBitcoin transactions are all public, but on Mt.Gox you can't see who the other side of a trade is.
- eridius 15y agoI think it's safe to say that Kevin knew the bitcoins he purchased were not on the up-and-up.
- tedunangst 15y agoHe knew the trades were unusual, but there are also other explanations for weird trades than dumping stolen goods.
- jrs235 15y agoExactly. He may have seen the unusual dumping of bitcoins as a planned crash. Someone who legitimately acquired them with the intention of doing this dumping in order to prove some point. To prove that these the account was hacked and the coins sold illegally, has anyone seen the police reports?
- praptak 15y ago"The exception to this rule is a "bona fide purchaser for value without notice". If someone has no reason to believe that property is stolen and buys it, then it's their property now. So sorry." This rule only applies in some law systems. Where I live you need both to perform all the reasonable checks and 3 years time to become the owner of the stolen property. If the original owner shows up before 3 years have passed then you have to get back whatever you have bought. This happens even if you have performed all of the reasonable legitimacy checks. One exception is land registration - entries in the public land register (even those obtained illegally) protect the purchasers from claims by the original owners (this does not apply to bad faith buyers.)
- jacques_chester 15y agoYou're right in that it will vary by jurisdiction. I guess I didn't use enough caveats. :D
- gte910h 15y agoAn exception in some places. In most places in the US, you are not the owner.