6 ms·
They were and are a really fucking dumb idea. A smoke detector has exactly one function. Make really irritating noise whenever something is wrong. And exactl
by brudgers 6y ago
They were and are a really fucking dumb idea.
A smoke detector has exactly one function.
Make really irritating noise whenever something is wrong.
And exactly two definitions of wrong: smoke and low power.
The incorporation of convenience features entirely defeated the purpose of smoke detectors. It made them less likely to save lives.
There are still IOT smoke detectors in the commercial space for air ducts. And instead of noise, they signal a monitored central station in facilities in working relationships with the local fire service. Hospitals for example.
That's not your house.
The limited life expectancy of smoke detectors created an attractive recurring purchase model for Nest. It over-ruled life safety effectiveness. I suspect, but have no evidence beyond circumstantial, that lawyers, regulators, and insurers all said things that made financial accountants remodel projections.
- nojokes 6y agoI like the second kind of wrong. My smoke sensors start to make random short bleeps. I have about 10 of them in our house. Usually it will take at least annoying 15 minutes to locate the culprit.
- seized 6y agoI disagree. My dumb detectors started false positives after just a few years. Their mute/silence buttons didn't work so burnt toast meant two minutes of screeching. No options for remote alerts (without external smart hardware). Batteries would only fail at night even after a few years. Or dust? Or carbon monoxide? Never knew, because the beeps were a terrible form of communication. Smoke detectors SHOULD have some safe, reliable smart technology. All my Protects have outlasted the simple Kiddes.
- brudgers 6y agoAfter a few years smoke alarms are supposed to be replaced. They have a lifespan based on radioactive decay of the detector. Making them $200 a pop makes this less likely. They are safe reliable technology. Convenience features make them less so. Because we live in a world where some people can’t even operate a toaster.
- tinus_hn 6y agoYou don’t replace your car because the windscreen wiper rubbers dried up. You could replace the cheap detector part and keep the expensive smart part. Of course the manufacturers would rather have you buy the smart part over and over again. Sounds like a great idea and now they have nothing.
- brudgers 6y agoThe Venn diagram of people who don't change batteries, can't reliably make toast, and want a feature rich smoke alarm is non-empty based on this thread.
- AstralStorm 6y agoWell, you could have a mains powered rechargable battery (or supercapacitor) backed detector. Then again, it better be designed so that the sensor part is replaceable and it fails loud. (Though neither supercapacitor nor nickel-* cells are very expensive, we put them in random MP3 players for $10 a pop.) The feature richness is a scam though.
- brudgers 6y agoThe half-life of commodity rechargeable batteries is significantly less than the half-life of Americium. And people who don't proactively replace smoke alarm batteries are unlikely to proactively change the alarms...changing out an alarm is a bigger job than changing batteries. A smoke alarm is not a consumer product.
- heisenzombie 6y agoI dunno, I don’t see a problem with progressive enhancement of a dumb device: Clearly, don’t control the screecher with a web-connected microcontroller. But if it’s a totally standard dumb fire alarm that also outputs a voltage to a microcontroller that sends an alert to your smart home platform of choice? I don’t see the downside. And if it has a 90% chance of alerting you that your fire alarm has gone off when you’re out of earshot of the irritating noise? Why not?
- brudgers 6y agoThe reason it’s a fucking dumb idea is in no small part because it doesn’t conform to our ordinary pattern recognition of really fucking dumb ideas. The Nest could be disabled by waving at it...It was a feature. There are smoke alarms you can connect to a central alarm panel. Alarm panels that can be monitored remotely. And monitoring services that will call you when there is an alarm. The difference is each element prioritizes life safety by conforming to life safety standards. An important dimension of these standards is saving the lives of firefighters. When everyone is out of the structure they don’t need to go into an actively burning building. If you are out of earshot of a smoke alarm, what can you do besides turn it off? Home IoT devices are not known for their security. Nor are they known for long term support. The article itself demonstrates that... A smoke alarm is not a consumer is always right device. There’s nothing stopping an Alexa skill that responds to the noise of a smoke alarm with a text to your phone.
- edent 6y ago> If you are out of earshot of a smoke alarm, what can you do besides turn it off? Come home. Or call the fire brigade. Or ask a neighbour to check. Or log into your home cameras to check for smoke.
- brudgers 6y agoNone of those gets anyone out of the house. None increases life safety. And people don't reason well about fire when it occurs. Your second alternative ought to be the first. But it isn't what you thought of first. That's normal when it comes to structures on fire. Why "come home" is before calling the fire service is because normal inclination is to want to save building contents from burning. On the way there, you would make a mental list. Arrive ready to go inside. It's how we are wired. Smoke alarms are the way they are not based on theory. They are the way they are based on experience. Not lay experience. Professional experience of fire fighters counting corpses and conducting after action debriefings and writing reports. An HN related example, http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca1/groups/ceda/documents/report/oak064503.pdf http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca1/groups/ceda/documents/repo... A person will run out of fingers and toes counting all the obviously bad ideas that contributed to the thirty six fatalities. And counting all the individuals who poorly assessed the life safety risk for the sake of convenience and lifestyle. Again, it's how we are wired. And why smoke alarms have to be required by law.
- ricardobeat 6y agoWhy are they less likely to save lives - isn't the smoke detector and alarm part exactly the same as a non-IoT device?
- grammarprofess 6y agoEverything is a bad idea until you realize that it's still better than the precedent one
- hellisothers 6y agoDo you have examples of Nests failing more frequently than normal alarms? The connectivity is not useless and is one of the reasons I bought them, 12 of them for my house. If you live in even a medium sized house you have a lot of rooms such that having ALL the alarms go of telling you the specific room the smoke is in can make a huge difference. Not to mention that these alarms do both types of smoke/fire and carbon monoxide all in one.
- brudgers 6y agoWhen a smoke alarm goes off, it’s telling you to get out of the house. The Nest design encourages opening an app on your iPhone instead. A smartphone has many uses but it is not a practical fire extinguisher. Each of its convenience features for non-critical events is potentially a deadly distraction when life is a matter of seconds. It’s the smoke that usually kills.
- alkonaut 6y ago> They were and are a really fucking dumb idea. I disagree > A smoke detector has exactly one function. Make really irritating noise whenever something is wrong. No that’s one of two functions. The other one is letting me know if there is something burning even when I’m not home. It’s not nearly as important as the first job and a device should never do the first job worse because of it. But it can come in handy. A good connected fire alarm can do all kinds of things like closing all windows or work as a siren for a home alarm. In no situation should they ever be dependent on a cloud service, not even for “additional” features beyond the beep-when-there-is-fire function.
- brudgers 6y agoYour disagreement is “the consumer is always right.” That you disagree by this rationale is why it is a dumb idea.
- alkonaut 6y agoWhat do you mean? I mean that it’s not a worse product because it’s connected (No smoke alarm should be worse than a dumb one at that job). And since there can be benefits it’s not a bad idea. Obviously if it has shorter lifespan, can fail in some way a dumb alarm couldn’t, then it’s not a good product.
- brudgers 6y agoThe original Nest could be disabled by waving at it. By design. It was a differentiation feature used for its marketing. There are exactly zero good ideas for user configuration of a smoke alarm.
- alkonaut 6y agoSo long as the alarm is a normal dumb smoke alarm and any additional features is on top of that, it’s fine. If you can screw it up, or the smart features adds any risk - it’s a bad product. I’m not arguing that no connected alarms are bad. I’m arguing that It’s possible, and easy, to make a connected alarm that is no worse than a dumb one . That’s a completely different argument. It’s trivial to make a lousy product. Even easier with a product that tries to be smart. That doesn’t make it a fundamental law that it has to be that way. I don’t doubt that Nest products are useless, their smart features require an internet connection which is a clear sign of trash in any home product. Taking a dumb alarm and putting a radio or other connection on it doesn’t (shouldn’t) affect the functionality. These alarms also existed since forever for larger buildings. No one would argue that they were less reliable than dumb alarms.
- sagolikasoppor 6y agoI have a large house so I have IoT smoke detectors because they are connected so if one goes off, everyone does. Its good because otherwise a fire could start in one section of the house without me waking up for example.