3 ms·
>This wasn't an insurrection, and none of your gaslighting will make it so. They literally discussed their plans for violent revolution openly on various socia
by krapp 6y ago
>This wasn't an insurrection, and none of your gaslighting will make it so.
They literally discussed their plans for violent revolution openly on various social media platforms for months beforehand. Who is gaslighting whom, here?
- Grieving 6y agoThey literally never did this. They didn't believe that the election was fair, and fought tooth and nail to make sure the results weren't certified. Even the whackiest of Q-believers, stupidly believed (and still do) that it would be the government that would step in to prevent a coup.
- alexc05 6y agoI think it is fair to say that no matter how much we go back and forth on this, we are never going to agree. The gulf between what you perceive and what I saw is far too great a chasm to cross. If we carried on, it'd probably get heated or it'd end up being a massive wasted effort. I've been through this rodeo too many times before. I spend the effort to go find objective sources that prove the claims I make only to be met with shifting goal posts and denialism. For example the link literally describing the PB getting declared a terrorist organization. We're just hand waving that one away are we? Anyways ... That was a rhetorical question. I've seen the way this all goes. In order to preserve my own sanity and respect the sanctity of hackernews' no flamewars policy I'm just going to tell you that I disagree and wish you a peaceful day.
- Grieving 6y ago> I think it is fair to say that no matter how much we go back and forth on this, we are never going to agree. The gulf between what you perceive and what I saw is far too great a chasm to cross. If we carried on, it'd probably get heated or it'd end up being a massive wasted effort. I've been through this rodeo too many times before. I spend the effort to go find objective sources that prove the claims I make only to be met with shifting goal posts and denialism. I feel the same. That song and dance gets old. My goal wasn't to come to an agreement, but to introduce a different perspective in a largely one-sided discussion. > For example the link literally describing the PB getting declared a terrorist organization. We're just hand waving that one away are we? It's kind of downstream from this discussion, no? That designation is contingent on the facts that we were directly debating. > In order to preserve my own sanity and respect the sanctity of hackernews' no flamewars policy I'm just going to tell you that I disagree and wish you a peaceful day. Thank you, you too. I know we aren't able to reconcile, but I do appreciate engaging with the other side on a more civil forum.
- krapp 6y agoThey believed they were acting under the direct orders of the President of the United States, and that the military and police were on their side. If you refuse to believe the words of the people involved, watch some of the videos[0] from the scene - that crowd wasn't all there to protest, a lot of them were out for blood and vengeance. [0]https://projects.propublica.org/parler-capitol-videos/ https://projects.propublica.org/parler-capitol-videos/
- Grieving 6y agoCan you point to a specific video? I watched livestreams as it was happening, and have seen a lot of the Parler videos. My impression both from the videos and from right-wing twitter in the lead-up to this event, is that some q believers thought that various government and military leaders were going to step in, expose, and arrest members of the "deep state". Some of the more out there ones thought that the "deep state" leaders would be executed for treason. They're insane, as is par for the course in American politics, but weren't attempting a violent revolution. The rhetoric of "stop the steal" was wholly consistent with that of "the resistance".
- alexc05 6y agoThere were shirts printed with > MAGA > Civil War > Jan 6th "It's just a prank bro" doesn't really hold a lot of water when the actions taken at the event look indistinguishable from what the "real" version would look like. The shirts: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/the-goods/22225538/capitol-insurrection-riot-sweatshirts-hats https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/the-go... Violent chat in their private channels: https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/capitol-riot-far-right-extremists-telegram-1120511/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/capitol-ri... An analysis and reporting of the Maga mob's garbage chats: https://idontspeakgerman.libsyn.com/77-capital-coup https://idontspeakgerman.libsyn.com/77-capital-coup (audio) There's just so much actual, verifiable evidence of what happened that it is stunning to me that anyone would come along and say "no they were just upset at what they think was unfair" But also why I don't really get involved in discussions with them anymore. If we can't come to terms around the existence of objective reality then anything further is a total waste of time. :)
- Grieving 6y ago> MAGA > Civil War > Jan 6th Rhetoric about civil war was on everyone's lips in 2020. Both conservatives and liberals increasingly expected one. Conservatives were more 'ready' for one, being opposed to the status quo. Stating that you're prepared to fight for your beliefs in an extremely heated and increasingly repressive political environment doesn't make you responsible for that environment. This is a lot like the whining about Trump's 'fight' rhetoric which his defense skewered with their mashup of more extreme rhetoric from his detractors. FWIW revolution was never going to happen though. Americans have no revolutionary potential. > The shirts: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/the-go https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/the-go... A handful of edgy shirts at a massive protest does not an insurrection make. > "It's just a prank bro" doesn't really hold a lot of water when the actions taken at the event look indistinguishable from what the "real" version would look like. I don't think you know much about what a "real" one looks like. > Violent chat in their private channels: https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/capitol-ri https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/capitol-ri... Again, a lot of empty hyperbole from a small minority, par for the course with 'the resistance', antifa, etc. > An analysis and reporting of the Maga mob's garbage chats: https://idontspeakgerman.libsyn.com/77-capital-coup https://idontspeakgerman.libsyn.com/77-capital-coup (audio) I've had to sit through I Don't Speak German before. Garbage, unsubstantive regurgitation of bourgeois talking-points. No thank you.