5 ms·
The first and most important question of course is to understand that having too much WIP is in fact bad. This is a well-understood concept in factories. Not e
by Animats 6y ago
The first and most important question of course is to understand that having too much WIP is in fact bad.
This is a well-understood concept in factories.
Not enough people today have ever been in a factory.
It's a classic problem with manufacturing plants that make a large number of different items. There, it's obvious - you have racks or piles or bins of partially finished product sitting around. Yet you can't avoid some of that, because machines have setup and teardown times. So you make a thousand stampings of thing A, which then wait for the next step. If you only made a lot of 100, there would be less work in progress, but more time the stamping machine wasn't running while the dies were changed. If you made a lot of 10,000, the stamping machine's efficiency would be higher but you'd have more work in progress. So, what's the optimal lot size?
This is a classic business school problem.[1] There's a whole theory of this, dating back to 1913.
Apple is famous for having botched this with their Macintosh factory in Fremont.[2] They centered their factory around an automated storage and retrieval system. This meant they could buffer a lot of work in process without making a visible mess. Wrong approach.
[1] https://www.allaboutlean.com/lot-size-part-1/ https://www.allaboutlean.com/lot-size-part-1/
[2] https://youtu.be/Dk306ZkNOuc https://youtu.be/Dk306ZkNOuc
- billfruit 6y agoSome of such analysis forms part of a now obscure discipline called 'Work Study'.
- whatshisface 6y agoOr a less obscure discipline called "operations research."
- sbayeta 6y agoThis is why SMED was developed
- beaconstudios 6y agoThe same problem arises in logistics, job queues in programming, and elsewhere. The study of stocks (aka buffers) and flows (aka processes) is the domain of system dynamics. Its a rather interesting field of study.
- elevation 6y agoI watched the video in [2]. I saw the automated retrieval system, some pick-and-place machines, some final-acceptance testing -- all aspects of the modern manufacturing processes. Aside from having a few more humans in the loop than you'd need with modern machinery, nothing there looks "botched." This article [3] suggests that Apple simply didn't have enough demand to make the factory successful. Success would have required additional automation such as adding pick and place for the larger components, automating the acceptance testing. [3]: https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/12/17/steve-jobs-wanted-to-build-apple-computers-in-fremont-why-didnt-it-work-out/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/12/17/steve-jobs-wanted-to-...
- xupybd 6y agoThere is a fantastic novel that explains this in a manufacturing context. As it explained through a fictional story it's an easy read and a great audiobook. The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt I didn't fully grasp the problem of too much WIP until I read that book.
- truemped 6y agoAuthor here. I loved the book and encourage everyone to read it. Use the Theory of Constraints to identify your bottleneck and then "limit wip" or elevate it.
- quickthrower2 6y agoDo you mean you are the author of that book or an author in general?
- cortesoft 6y agoPlaying Factorio helps to demonstrate this. At its core, Factorio is about turning a few base materials into useful things, with many intermediate parts. Everything you build, then, is eventually competing with those few basic as materials. The first time I played, I would see some base part being produced faster than it was consumed, and my thought was I should store the excess product, so that the factories creating those products would not back up and stop functioning. This would let me have a buffer, and keep those intermediate material producing machines running at full capacity. Now that I had this buffer of intermediate materials that was growing, I would try to add more factories that used those materials for the next intermediate material. However, the next intermediate material would also need other intermediate materials, so I would have to expand the number of factories producing raw materials to feed those other producers. However, additional raw materials were also consumed by the factories that were ALREADY overproducing. This lead to an attempt at a delicate balancing act, to get the number of factories for each type exactly right. I would add some to one material, then have to add more to another. It was impossible. What I finally learned is that I had to let the factories over producing backup and stop producing. That way, more raw materials would be leftover for the things I was short on. This back pressure allowed the factory to self balance. Increasing the buffer on something is only useful if the usage is highly variable. Then, you need a small buffer but not too big of one.
- jkhdigital 6y agoBackpressure is the most important force in any production process. Now if only I could figure out how to apply it to my personal life...
- brylie 6y agoYeah same here! I'm just thinking aloud, but let's consider time and money as our scarce resources. We can perhaps put backpressure on time-sink activities, such as endless scrolling Netflix, and open up those time resources for creative hobbies. This essentially boils down to replacing a consumer habit/mindset with one of creativity and self-expression. Similarly, living in a small apartment and not paying for a storage unit can put backpressure on material acquisitions.