3 ms·
Not that everything is political, but it appears that the two judges in the majority were appointed by Republicans and the dissenter was appointed by a Democrat
by gnicholas 6y ago
Not that everything is political, but it appears that the two judges in the majority were appointed by Republicans and the dissenter was appointed by a Democrat. If they end up having an en banc hearing, the composition of the full Eleventh Circuit (excluding senior status judges) is seven Republican appointees and five Democrat appointees. There are also more Republican appointees among the senior status judges.
Of course, this decision shouldn't be over-politicized; I only mention this because it is a relevant consideration in predicting the likelihood of an en banc rehearing, and the possible outcome.
My sense (as a former lawyer) is that en banc rehearings are somewhat more likely when the majority of the judges would vote to reverse. Given the composition of the Eleventh Circuit, this theory would predict that there wouldn't be a rehearing, which would leave this to SCOTUS to resolve.