3 ms·
"IMHO if the majority of listeners misunderstand your talk and don't get the point you're trying to make, then you made a bad talk." Does not follow. It is als
by jerf 15y ago
"IMHO if the majority of listeners misunderstand your talk and don't get the point you're trying to make, then you made a bad talk."
Does not follow. It is also possible that he has made a hard point, which the brains of the readers have a hard time representing with their internal conceptualizations, therefore misunderstand, then act on those misunderstandings. I think the presentation is perfectly clear, and do not see any obvious way it can be made wildly easier to understand.
Quality of communication is not just bounded by the quality of the sender, it is bounded by the quality of the recipient as well. The point this presentation is trying to make is intrinsically hobbled by the fact that many people cognitively will only perceive something that boils down to "PATTERNS GOOD" (hooray!) or "PATTERNS BAD" (boo! flames!), and "PATTERNS DOGMA A LOSSY TRANSLATION OF SUPERIOR ORIGINAL PATTERNS CONCEPT" doesn't into either of those buckets very well (the distinction between patterns dogma and patterns idea being a tricky one all by itself), and if that's how one approaches it, it's easy to see how it simply falls into the "bad" bucket.