4 ms·
Marco contradicts himself: Neither Google nor Microsoft will ever be able to tailor their software to other manufacturers’ specific (and varied) hardware devic
by wvenable 15y ago
Marco contradicts himself:
Neither Google nor Microsoft will ever be able to tailor their software to other manufacturers’ specific (and varied) hardware devices
...followed by...
Anyone can cobble together the same processors, DRAM, flash, and radios as Apple, put them into a plastic case
What is the iPad? It's a touch-sensitive screen. It has a border and a few buttons. What is every non-Apple tablet? The exact same thing. In terms of other hardware, tablets are far less varied than PCs.
Microsoft and Google don't have to tailor their operating systems to varied hardware -- in terms of interface, all tablets are the same. The problem is they're a few years behind Apple in the whole software ecosystem.
The big point, and here Macro and I would certainly agree, the iPad has a reasonable software ecosystem and everyone else doesn't. I don't see Android or Windows making a dent in this anytime soon but, assuming the tablet market has legs, it will happen eventually. But for now, it doesn't seem like a non-Apple tablet is a good buy.
- pohl 15y agoin terms of interface, all tablets are the same. How true is this? I thought some tablets have navigation buttons while others do not. I also thought that there was some variation in screen sizes, and therefore screen real-estate. I also thought that Microsoft, in particular, seeks to support older windows software (I'm getting this notion from the Win8 video that was released the week prior to WWDC), and therefore has additional user interface concerns. Isn't there at least one tablet out there that has a stylus? I understand how easy it is to think "glass rectangles; how different can they be?" but I think that's a big mistake. Because of this, I disagree with the notion that the author contradicted himself.
- wvenable 15y agoI stand by my argument. While some tablets have more or less buttons, that is hardly a significant factor. In some new Android tablets, where the OS demands dedicated back and menu buttons, are implemented on screen in software. It's really just not that much of differentiating factor. Screen size is a bigger factor but we've already seen that play out on smartphones. And despite a number of 7" tablets, the market is clearly leaning towards a 10" form factor as standard. Microsoft does seek to support older windows software but the user interface concerns comes from the fact that they're bringing that to touchable glass rectangle hardware.
- wonderzombie 15y agoUnless we're speaking very narrowly in terms of hardware, I disagree. I've never used Android on the tablet, but I've owned Android phones for years. I own an iPod Touch and an iPad. The device's interface and the way it influences apps & app developers makes a huge difference. On Android, menu is functionally equivalent to right-click, which means it either hides complexity or it's a dumping ground, depending on your perspective. I don't care for it. The lack of a OS-level back button on iOS means most apps put a back button somewhere on screen, or there's page-swiping. Generally you know where pressing that button will take you. The vast majority of the time it will never take you out of your current application. That is not the case on Android; you can dump yourself back to the home screen from a web browser if you hit Back one too many times. And then there's the "activity stack," an OS-level concept that interacts with the Home and Back buttons. Maybe the buttons themselves are not differentiators, but they imply or enforce different assumptions which in turn inform the way people use and develop for the device.
- wvenable 15y agoYou mention hardware in your first line but absolutely everything else you said has to do with the software only.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoIt's funny how so many people come to the same, in my opinion correct, conclusion but get there for all the wrong reasons. Marco almost gets it in the first paragraph, then stumbles around trying to explain it. There's nothing to explain; people want the iPad because it is a desirable "sexy" device, plain and simple. Trying to go further and you've missed the point entirely. It's the cumulation of years of brand strengthening, good products, and good advertising. If you ask the average person who wants an iPad (and I've done this) they won't be able to tell you any one thing, and no "apps" have absolutely nothing to with it. All they know is that the iPad is cool, people who have one are cool, and they must have one as well.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoI disagree with this. "Sexy" can get you in the door, but only if you actually solve some need (perhaps not yet known) can you develop market share. If the iPad had only sold 240K machines the first year then you'd say "Its just a sexy device without solving a real problem." But it did much more than that. So you go back and ask "What was it?" And that is what market research is all about. I don't know, I've not surveyed thousands of iPad owners why they bought, how much they use now, if they would upgrade, so I can only go by the limited exposure to friends, family, and various hacker types. The itch it seemed to scratch, which was un-met by the 'touch' was "instant on access to email and web." The 'conventional' wisdom was that this "wasn't enough" to justify a $500 - $900 purchase. Or a laptop would be the answer. Apparently the wisdom was wrong. There are other things it does of course, and more all the time. I got into a fierce one sided debate inside Google where I was advocating e-readers were important and being countered with "your stupid, I can do that on my phone, no one will buy an e-reader who isn't stupid." (Almost word for word, seriously) You can't see what you can't see. So while I agree that a strong brand can sell stuff which isn't useful, developing beyond the afficiandos takes actual value which the iPad (and tablets) seem to have.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoI'm upvoting you for a well-written, well-reasoned reply but I'm not convinced. Chrome OS's sweet spot is instant on web and email also, but I'd venture to guess it isn't going to sell nearly as well as the iPad has/will. Certainly it's not as good in other areas, but if that really is what this trend boils down to it should be a big success as well. I've never heard a potential iPad owner give a reason for wanting an iPad. The iPad is a fashion accessory. I've seen people crowd around them at parties during the early days lustfully wanting it, but no one mentioned apps or email or anything like that. Or anything about the experience at all.
- zmmmmm 15y ago> It has a border and a few buttons. What is every non-Apple tablet? The exact same thing. In terms of other hardware, tablets are far less varied than PCs > Microsoft and Google don't have to tailor their operating systems to varied hardware -- in terms of interface, all tablets are the same. This seems to be the logic so often applied to Apple. 1) Assume only Apple endorsed features are important 2) Disregard all non-Apple endorsed features on competitors 3) Declare all competitors are just inferior copies of Apple devices The reality is that there are extremely useful features on the non-Apple tablets. While it certainly remains to be seen how much consumer interest they get, it's very premature to write them off. I especially think that Google has a great chance to differentiate with its online services - more so than on the phone.