2 ms·
Apple is very reluctant to put all of their heart in patent battles, to the point you start wondering if maybe internal patent attorneys are calling the shots a
by rasz 6y ago
Apple is very reluctant to put all of their heart in patent battles, to the point you start wondering if maybe internal patent attorneys are calling the shots and like the status quo a little too much.
They pretty much intentionally lost S3TC patent case opting not to push for patent invalidation https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/itc-judge-rules-that-apple-infringes-two-s3-graphics-patents-124892519.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/itc-judge-rules-tha... The thing about s3tc is _its Apple own technology_, just renamed and repurposed.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S3_Texture_Compression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S3_Texture_Compression "This mode operates similarly to mode 0xC0 of the original Apple Video codec." is an understatement. S3 directly lifted Apple patented QuickTime Road Pizza technique of encoding 4 colors using 2 values (same math, same values, same purpose, no prior art acknowledgment), to ~10 years later sue and win.
- nhoughto 6y agoPretty strange world where losing 300mil to this lot is a net win to maintain the hostile patent environment against their competitors. I guess it’s pretty similar to Apple acquiring the patents and then suing competitors.. but without all the ill will that directly suing companies off a weak base brings. Bit sad that it all rationally makes sense.
- onetimemanytime 6y ago>>They pretty much intentionally lost S3TC patent case opting not to push for patent invalidation Do you have any inside knowledge or just guessing the strategy of the lawyers in the courtroom?
- rasz 6y agoThey didnt even try to file a case with USPTO's Patent Trial and Appeal Board. Their iPhone "strategy" was avoiding the matter altogether, stripping S3TC assets and support from the software (still in the SoC).
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> S3 directly lifted Apple patented QuickTime Road Pizza technique of encoding 4 colors using 2 values (same math, same values, same purpose, no prior art acknowledgment), to ~10 years later sue and win. This seems like the type of thing that an amicus brief could point out regardless of Apple's strategy in the case. Did that not happen?