8 ms·
Every so often a patent troll story comes up on HN, and people like me bitch about how broken the system is and get group therapy from shouting into the wind on
by freedomben 6y ago
Every so often a patent troll story comes up on HN, and people like me bitch about how broken the system is and get group therapy from shouting into the wind on a web forum.
What can we actually do. How do we start fixing this problem?
- taf2 6y agoThink carefully about who you vote for. Get involved in the process- like anything unless you actually really care and have the means or can turn it into your means most likely you will move onto something else...
- mdorazio 6y agoThe problem is I'm pretty sure this needs to be fixed at the national legislative level. There are somewhere between few and no electable congressional candidates who actually care enough about patents to stand up to lobbying. And there are very few people outside the microcosm of the tech community who care enough about patent reform to prioritize it above other mainstream issues. So what's the practical game plan that doesn't take 20+ years?
- erosenbe0 6y agoYou tie it to something strategic, even if it the relationship is loose. We have a chip shortage right? And an American manufacturing crisis, right? "We need to eliminate trolling waste and abuse for national security. In Asia they don't have this dysfunction and we're ceding ground to adversaries simply to make lawyering trolls rich!"
- BurningFrog 6y agoThat can work for the 1-3 top issues in the country. This issue is maybe in the top 1000.
- tombert 6y agoI've wondered that too. How can we realistically boycott the companies that abuse patents? I suppose I could stop using Apple products, but most current software jobs require some form of smartphone for authentication, so I need an iPhone or Android phone, thus supporting Google or Samsung or LG or one of the other big megacorps that abuse the American patent system. I feel like the only thing that could conceivably happen is to fight fire with fire, and start suing these companies and challenging these patents to a point where it's so expensive for them that they lobby congress to regulate it better. Even still, I have doubts that that would even work, since it's still probably more profitable for them to keep all their ridiculous patents than the loss in legal fees.
- erosenbe0 6y agoThe megacorps are forced to file many patents for defensive purposes, either for protection against each other or the NPEs. Technical bulletins, disclosures, and scientific publications showing the obviousness of ridiculous NPE patents just don't seem to be enough. The juries must be receiving bad info on what to do.
- jlarocco 6y ago> for protection against each other or the NPEs Unfortunately, a patent portfolio doesn't protect against NPEs. A patent portfolio lets a company settle patent disputes with cross-licensing deals, or counter-sue with a "no you" argument. An NPE doesn't have a product, so there's no reason to cross-license, and no way their product can violate any other patent.
- mr_toad 6y ago> How can we realistically boycott the companies that abuse patents? You mean law firms? Most patent trolls don’t make or sell anything. There’s nothing to boycott.
- henvic 6y agoWatch The Patent Scam, by the X-Plane's (flight simulator) founder Austin Meyer. https://www.thepatentscam.com/ https://www.thepatentscam.com/
- gruez 6y agoI always find "watch this documentary" to be pointless. If the person's already convinced that patent abuse is bad, they don't need to watch a 2 hour video to reconfirm their beliefs. If the person is sitting on the fence or not convinced, there are better ways to provide information to them than getting them to stare at a screen for 2 hours.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- boomboomsubban 6y agoIf that was the only solution presented I would agree, but in an online forum with several other answers someone providing an overly detailed source is handy. Most people may not be interested, but some might be.
- mitchdoogle 6y agoI disagree with your general sentiment. The people here reading these comments may be on the fence. Maybe they're leaning one way or another. Maybe they need some more convincing. Someone who wants to learn more can benefit greatly from a documentary or a good article on the subject. And these comments don't just exist in this moment. They will be available in search for a long time to come.
- xoa 6y ago>What can we actually do. How do we start fixing this problem? Do the hard grunt work of getting enough of a broad base of political support for Congress to enact reform. Seriously, that's what it comes down to. And it's not some impossible thing even for a minority so long as it's focused. Precisely because majorities don't really pay much attention to such things and these days are fairly fixed, even a fraction of a percentage of the vote that always votes and will do so based on a single or very small set of issues can have an outsized impact. In this case, the goal would probably be a few very targeted things. My nomination would be 1) Eliminate software and "business method" patents entirely, with the argument that software is already covered by copyright and vague ideas shouldn't be patentable, and 2) actually fund the USPTO to a much higher degree and give it more teeth so more patents can be taken down early. I don't think it's an impossible dream. It's an issue that doesn't fit into typical polarization, since there are major business benefits both ways. There are easy outrageous examples of patents that will strike the average person as obviously wrong. It's something Congress can do without the slightest question. There will be economic interests against it, but there are ones for it as well. And the tide has been turning a bit on IP maximalism. I've written my Senators at least, talking about some of the personal harms I've seen as a developer. I got replies. If nothing else, everyone should do that and not just post on the internet. They certainly are unlikely to immediately change their stances, but they absolutely pay attention to letters because so few write them. If they start seeing enough people concerned about an issue, they will if nothing else give it some much higher level attention. Unfortunately I don't know of any national advocacy/lobbying organizations devoted purely to patent reform. The EFF does some good work there, but they've got a wider umbrella of critical issues to fight as well. I donate what I can to them but it'd be nice if there was some place just for this too. Still, I hope to see some progress in my lifetime on reigning them back in from when they were invented in court in the 80s.
- conanbatt 6y agoOr dont do patents at all.
- birdyrooster 6y agoPatents were made for a time before ubiquitous multinational corporations. If there are multiple sources of truth and markets for what is protected invention, then it greatly dilutes the power of that patent. This ends up hamstringing the countries most dependent on patenting to encourage innovation because we are still beholden to foreign interest who file their patents with the USPO or sell to an American troll. The US is the most fastidious in their preservation of patent law despite its many flaws and this is why we will lose out most in the global turning against protected invention.
- tschwimmer 6y agoLike most major structural issues, nothing.
- gameswithgo 6y agoWhat do people turn to when the legal system fails them?
- dvt 6y ago> What do people turn to when the legal system fails them? This doesn't mean anything. It's just cynicism masquerading as fatalism. We thankfully don't live in an absolutist monarchy. Laws can change, and in fact do change all the time. Election upsets happen all the time. But like a sibling comment said, no one wants to actually go out and do the grunt work. Whining on Twitter is certainly easier than canvassing a neighborhood.
- winter_blue 6y ago> What can we actually do. How do we start fixing this problem? Write draft legislation that would fix the problem. Propose this to your country's legislature (Congress in the US, Parliament, etc). Push for the new law. Form or join an organization that writes and pushes for legislation that will fix the patent law mess. Etc.
- freedomben 6y agoFascinating, thank you! I hadn't thought of that, but that's the kind of audacious (even outrageous) thing that while extremely unlikely to happen, it could. I like the way you think!
- mxcrossb 6y agoApple apparently has 308 million dollars of incentives to fix the system, so maybe that’s a good start.
- harles 6y agoBut they also won $500m+ from Samsung using the same system. Not to mention the defensive position it gives them. It seems like an overwhelmingly net positive for Apple.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoIf you are the CTO of Microsoft you set up the world's largest patent troll after you leave Microsoft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures I guess if you are a tech CTO, you don't beat them, you join them. The sad part of Myhrvold's troll company is that it quickly spilled over into sectors other than software and "tech". Sectors that did not necessarily have the same knee-jerk negative reaction to the patent system (because despite its flaws, they depended on it).
- hourislate 6y agoCompanies like Apple, AMZN, MSFT, have enough resources and money to change the system but it wouldn't benefit them in the end. A few hundred million might seem like a lot to us but it's trivial to them. Sure they will defend themselves, they've got a lot of Lawyers on payroll that need to do something to earn their salaries. I can't imagine the carnage they could collectively unleash on the Judge, Jury, County, State, etc if they really wanted to? But it isn't worth the time, money or effort. At the end of the day it's just pay the "Parking Ticket" and move on.
- rz2k 6y agoStrategically, it is a barrier to entry for small competitors who can't afford the legal defense. That doesn't mean that Apple and Google are intentionally trying to preserve the legal environment for patent trolls to operate, but on some level it still is in their interest.
- mitchdoogle 6y agoThey know at some point they will play the role of the troll
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoDon't try to fix hard large-scale political problems. Fix easy local problems. Or invest in seasteading.
- 252452d 6y agoAll you'll hear from this place is that you "need to contact your representatives" or some nonsense. We need to rethink society and part of that is dismantling most if not all IP law. Maybe some of you will understand when hundreds of thousands or millions of people in the developing world die needlessly because the vaccine isn't made free, even in cases where it was publicly funded. "Hacker" News is the last place I'd go looking for real insight.
- breck 6y agoBig lies are labels spread widely without backing datasets. One thing everyone can do is start spreading a big truth (a label not widely shared but that fits a plethora of data far better): copyrights and patents are the opposite of property rights. One better description for IP is #imaginaryproperty. People who support them should be shamed. Because of IP bad medicine is encouraged, bad news is encouraged, bad inequity is encouraged, bad education is encouraged. Equitable progress (and progress in general), is a fraction of what it could be. Changing this one rule and shifting our energies from endlessly regurgitating old ideas to gardening great new ones will lead to a golden era of progress in area like healthcare, education, and equity. #EndIp. #LiberateIdeas. Start sharing big truths and fight big lies. The people will pick up on it.
- fsflover 6y agoSupport Electronic Frontier Foundation: https://www.eff.org/issues/patents https://www.eff.org/issues/patents.
- TuringNYC 6y agoStart adding a "Patent troll advance recovery fee" line item to your bills (even if it is just a break-out of the total cost), even for minor items and SaaS transactions so people see the impact to their own wallet.
- nikanj 6y agoCreate a startup, have a multi-billion dollar exit, then use some hundreds of millions for lobbying
- Kliment 6y agoDon't work with/for companies that use patents. Don't consent to companies using your work to file patents. If they do anyway, publish prior art where possible. Write down and publish as many things as possible to enable prior art searches. If an important case affects a field you've been working on for decades, actively help victims find prior art. Consistently vote against IP maximalists wherever you have an opportunity. Don't have relationships with IP maximalists. Remind the general public about how bad and stupid patents are when you have the opportunity. Don't buy products that advertise using "patented technology" or "patent pending". If you have no choice, buy used. If you are in control of a company's patent strategy, file lots of provisional patents then abandon them, so they show up in the database when patent examiners search for prior art. Financially support victims of patent attacks and help them get as many patents invalidated as possible.
- notahacker 6y agoCollective action isn't going to help with trolls with the resources (and case) to go up against Apple, but should kill off a lot of the frivolous "it's cheaper to license than fight" patent licensing demands. If a troll knows a license demand issued to a particular company will meet with the entire industry pooling resources to invalidate the patent they're trying to individually claim royalties for, it suddenly becomes an unprofitable business model (or at least, very unprofitable to demand licenses from companies participating in the scheme). Fundable since "patent insurance" is already a thing companies budget for, and probably doesn't require any legal changes to work.
- dennis_jeeves 6y agoThe patent problem is only the tip the iceberg, if you are unlucky or observant enough you will notice that several other things are broken like health care or housing. All this points to larger problem that many thinkers are in denial, that is of humans themself. Humans in general are terribly flawed and that cannot be fixed with laws.
- dennis_jeeves 6y agoThe patent problem is only the tip the iceberg, if you are unlucky or observant enough you will notice that several other things are broken like health care or housing. All this points to larger problem that many thinkers are in denial, that is of humans themself. Humans in general are terribly flawed and that problem can be only marginally alleviated with laws, activism etc.