3 ms·
The per-mile death rate is something like 750 times greater driving than flying. So a 1500 mile flight is as dangerous as a 2 mile drive to the airport.
by colechristensen 6y ago
The per-mile death rate is something like 750 times greater driving than flying.
So a 1500 mile flight is as dangerous as a 2 mile drive to the airport.
- ergocoder 6y agoOh man I was expecting a much higher difference.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- imoverclocked 6y agoMakes sense since there is only about 2 miles of runway traveled at either end.
- tzs 6y agoPer mile isn't really that good a measure for either flying or driving, because the risk of both flying and driving depends on where the miles are. For driving, the risk is much higher in cities on surface streets than it is on freeways between cities, for example. So a 10 mile round trip to the grocery store and back would probably be orders of magnitude more dangerous per mile than an 800 mile round trip from Los Angeles to San Francisco and back. But your chances of dying on the grocery store trip and your chances of dying at one of the ends of your LA/SF trip would be roughly the same. Same with flying. Takeoff, climbing to cruising altitude, cruising, descending for landing, and landing all have different risk profiles. A long trip is much safer per mile than a short trip because most of it is spent cruising at high altitude which is the safest part of the trip, but the overall risk is usually going to be higher on the long trip. Driving is further complicated because you have a lot more control over your safety when driving than you do when flying. When I've flown from LA to SF, it was probably about the same risk no matter what time of day I went. When I've driven from LA to SF, I've generally been able to pick times of day when there was little traffic at the ends, and there were generally no other cars within a couple miles of me on the freeway. That should have put my risk way below the average driving risk. (Note: I am not claiming that I am a more skilled or safer driver than average!). It was still probably more risky than flying, but not orders of magnitude more risky.
- edoceo 6y agoSo, you're the other car I see on 101 at 3am :)
- addicted 6y agoThe commenters argument is illogical. The commenter is engaging in 2 activities. Driving a car and then taking a plane. The fact that driving a car is riskier than taking a plane does not mean that that taking a plane that is 30x riskier than other planes doesn’t affect their risk. These are 2 independent risk events. If the taking plane part of your travel schedule becomes more risky, your overall risk also rises. The fact that driving a car is extremely risky has nothing to do with what price they should be willing to pay for the increased risk they would be taking flying a riskier plane.