4 ms·
> Cloth masks at a community level are basically wearing the same condom everyday and the condom is full of holes. That's not an accurate comparison at all, an
by bluefirebrand 6y ago
> Cloth masks at a community level are basically wearing the same condom everyday and the condom is full of holes.
That's not an accurate comparison at all, and I think you have completely missed the point.
Using a condom perfectly results in the fewest pregnancies. Using it typically (ie, once in a while you have one break or slip off) results in more pregnancies than perfect use, but still many less than unprotected sex.
The same logic should hold for masks.
Using them perfectly (ie single use, medical grade quality) results in the fewest infections. Using them typically (ie, non-medical grade cloth mask, wearing the same one more than once) results in more than the perfect use but still less than being unmasked. It is not a "rain dance"
If you are trying to make an argument that wearing a mask makes you equally as likely to get infected as being unmasked, I don't know what to tell you. You're just straight up wrong.
Edit - because you added your article link after I was already replying: you cannot generalize the usefulness of masks on healthcare workers who are typically very close to patients and breathing the same air as them, touching the same surfaces as them for extended periods of time to the usefulness to a community of people who are supposed to be sticking 6 feet apart.
Yeah if you are standing a foot from a sick person wearing a mask and they cough in your eye, and you get sick, it's gonna seem like the mask did nothing.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoUsing a condom that leaks repeatedly results in MORE pregnancies. Because the biological agent is never disposed of. And it keeps being applied over and over day after day. It's why you wouldn't want your surgeon to walk in to your operation with the mask he just used from the previous operation. It's also basic medical hygiene theory. The same reason that washing hands is effective because germs are transmissable via numerous vectors.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoYou're doing some serious mental gymnastics here. Yes, using things that are broken means they don't perform their intended function very effectively. That doesn't imply that using non-broken versions of those things is less effective somehow. That's not how the transitive property works. Edit - again because you're super edit happy. > It's why you wouldn't want your surgeon to walk in to your operation with the mask he just used from the previous operation No, ideally of course not. But given the choice between "surgeon wearing the old mask" and "surgeon wearing no mask at all" I think I prefer the old mask. Would you seriously just prefer the surgeon to breathe directly into whatever open cavity you have during the surgery?
- nickthemagicman 6y agoIf the last patient had an infectious disease then yes, no mask is much better than a mask. Breathing on me > contaminated infectious rag in the O.R.
- astrange 6y ago> It's why you wouldn't want your surgeon to walk in to your operation with the mask he just used from the previous operation. There is actually no evidence that surgical masks are protective during surgery. Mainly because nobody wants to do the experiment, but still.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoThere are legitimate studies that demonstrate that masks combined with proper mask usage is at least somewhat effective at preventing disease transmission. See some of my previous posts for those.
- bbarnett 6y agoYour cloth mask doesn't protect you from others. It protects others from you.
- astrange 6y agoIt does also protect you from others. The "it protects others from you" was propaganda to get around public health officials lying that masks didn't protect you unless you were a doctor in which case it worked for some reason. It doesn't perfectly protect you, but anything helps. A KN95/N95 is more effective and covering the eyes is better yet.
- Spivak 6y agoYeah the idea that masks somehow are one-way is baffling to me. You’re somehow preventing particles from leaving your mouth while simultaneously breathing in those same particles from the outside. If that were true you might consider flipping the mask inside out.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoI think of it this way: if we are both wearing masks, your mask is going to block way more of your particles than my mask is, and vice versa.
- bbarnett 6y agoThe purpose of cloth/lower quality masks, is to reduce, not eliminate spread. When breathing in, air is drawn around the edges. Thus, if the virus is airborne around you, you'll breath it in. If you have the virus, and are exhaling, the goal is to stop large droplets of moisture, which carry further, from exiting the mask. They are larger, hence, they get blocked and absorbed by the mask. Further, when breathing out, air is slowed, and also again passes around the edge of the mask. This reduces the spread, and is also why '6 feet' is recommended as a distance to keep from people. Again, this isn't about protecting you, but protecting others if you're infected, spreading, and per-symptomatic. FYI, in most non-US countries ... this isn't a debate. It's just accepted. For example in Canada, politicians of all stripes, left/right/whatever, agree on such basic concepts. We also didn't have weird things with public servants lying about basic mask protocols. I'll put this another way. If you're spreading, and wear no mask? Being a few feet from someone, and talking, isn't going to just get the virus in their mouth. Inhaled. It gets it in their eyes, on their face, their clothes, the list goes on and on. Masks are about reducing that kind of spread! Do they help you? A little bit, sure. But thaw's not the point. The point is to protect others! The cynic in me thinks "What an American attitude. It's all about me, screw protecting others!"