4 ms·
For a pandemic it's probably reasonable to err on the side of caution with the over-cleaning and arbitrary/inconsistent safety precautions, but I do wish we cou
by bluefirebrand 6y ago
For a pandemic it's probably reasonable to err on the side of caution with the over-cleaning and arbitrary/inconsistent safety precautions, but I do wish we could have found a slightly less restrictive approach than we did.
I have a lot of friends very angry at the anti-maskers for their behavior, showing up in stores unmasked and such. And that's reasonable to be mad I suppose.
But I also know the anti-mask people are just as mad at the rest of us, and from their perspective they are just as justified in it.
Wonder if knowing more about Terror Management Theory could help us navigate this friction better, and find some common ground. Or if we need different approaches altogether
- lukifer 6y agoYes, context matters, and sometimes even irrational instincts can end up being correct, especially under uncertainty, which was definitely true of the first few months of COVID. I'm less concerned about purely useless interventions, than counter-productive ones (or: a useless intervention A, which creates a psychological security blanket that subsumes motivation for high-yield intervention B). Even stranger, I've also seen individuals under-react and over-react at the same time! ("Sure, I attended $LARGE_PUBLIC_EVENT, but we all wore masks, except while eating, and I've been taking lots of Vitamin D.") For the over-reactors, I think aligning social norms with the best-science-for-now is achievable with simple rules and consistent messaging (that cohort wants to keep busy with rituals and precautions and social enforcement). For better or worse, our culture got a few simple memes to stick: wears masks in public, six-feet social distancing, outdoors is safer than indoors, limit socializing to "pods". For those in denial, that's a thornier problem, and I frankly don't have any ideas. Whatever the context, challenging someone in denial tends to result in them doubling-down on it. Sometimes social pressure or law enforcement can cajole someone into adopting a rule they don't like; but it can just as easily backfire into tribal counter-signaling, or individual "bravery signaling" (itself a sort of psychic ward against fear). And in fairness: it's not hard to imagine counter-factuals where the official recommendations really are useless or worse ("duck and cover").
- Yhippa 6y agoThroughout history the way these pandemics were dealt with was through quarantine. The fact that people were going into stores at all during this thing seems to be an affordance we never had in the past so I'm okay with arbitrary restrictions until it's proven wrong.
- oliv__ 6y agoYou don't deserve your freedom
- cgriswald 6y agoWe had mandated precautions here that were ultimately meaningless, but could have been meaningful and I can accept those as acceptable in the absence of information. However, when new information came in and counties all around us were completely removing certain precautions that weren’t helpful, my county merely “eased” some of the same precautions and in some cases did other things that effectively forced the same precautions on us. (For instance when parks were re-opened, they made it difficult to park near them.) We also had precautions here that I suspect wouldn’t have been meaningful even if the virus had been Captain Trips. I find myself loathe to trust the county with something like this in the future. (The state, on the other hand, did a pretty okay job all things considered.)
- feoren 6y agoSo what if anti-maskers feel justified in their own perspective? From the perspective of Jeffrey Dahmer, killing and eating people is justified. What is the point of making that comment, other than muddying the waters with some false equivalency nonsense? Anti-maskers are awful, awful people. It is reasonable to be mad at them because they are killing people; their anger is not based on reason and it is not equivalent.
- totony 6y ago>they are killing people how so?
- feoren 6y agoAre you asking me to educate you on how disease transmission occurs? I'll need help understanding where you're coming from here. Do you know what a virus is? Do you think the Earth is flat? You at least seem to be able to read, so that's a good start -- you're somewhere between the stone age and the bronze age then.
- totony 6y agoYou do not have to make personal attacks. To enlighten you about nuance, think about this: - Is driving a car the same as killing people? - Is selling junk food the same as killing people?
- mikem170 6y agoInfluenza kills 250k to 650k people a year [0], year after year after year. By your logic does that make anyone who hasn't been wearing a mask during flu season for all years past a killer? Or is there something different about flu deaths, but not covid deaths?
- feoren 6y agoDo you hear yourself? Because the flu kills more people, it's OK to drive drunk? It's OK to throw rocks off of highway overpasses and tall buildings? How can you call people who do that killers, when they're causing fewer deaths than the flu!? There are plenty of countries where people do wear masks during flu season if they feel like they might be sick. Yes, an anti-masker who would berate and assault people on buses for wearing a mask during flu season is fighting for the explicit goal of increasing random, avoidable deaths of strangers and is therefore a killer/terrorist.
- xorcist 6y ago> it's probably reasonable to err on the side of caution Sure, but it's far from clear what the side of caution is. Naively, the side of caution would be to not disturb the education of our young, and that preventive care still works, and the other big public health problems we do know how to fix. Yet, we see country after country opening restaurants while schools are still closed. This with a disease we know is less prevalent and spreads less among the young than other epidemics such as influenza. The side of caution is completely missing from this picture.