4 ms·
It’s a little more complicated, lightbulbs where very much a useful thing before Edison and several other improvements occurred from 1802 to Edison’s 1879 paten
by Retric 6y ago
It’s a little more complicated, lightbulbs where very much a useful thing before Edison and several other improvements occurred from 1802 to Edison’s 1879 patent and the actual breakthrough of a cheap bulb reaching 1200 hours occurred after that patent. Warren de la Rue for example had an efficient and long lasting design that was simply to expensive for mass production. Henry Woodward is arguably the first inventor of a practical bulb using carbon rods in nitrogen filled bulbs, though his business failed and he sold the patent to Edison.
Critically, it was really electric infrastructure more than the physical bulb design that resulted in GE’s success. Arc lamp’s had become very popular for street lighting through the 1870’s, which really set the stage for lighting alternatives.
- WalterBright 6y ago> practical bulb using carbon rods in nitrogen filled bulbs Arc lamps are good for search lights, but they suck enormous amounts of power, will burn your eyes if you glance at them, and are totally unsuitable for residential lighting. Just imagine someone lighting up your living room with an arc welder - it's the same thing. You'd go blind. Your argument seriously underestimates the utility of Edison's high voltage, low current design. It persisted with little change up until just recently when LEDs finally displaced them. It's a pretty amazing run. de la Rue's design failed because it relied on a platinum filament - not practical. It also relied on low voltage and high current - a dead end.
- neolog 6y ago> Just imagine someone lighting up your living room with an arc welder - it's the same thing. You'd go blind. You could use a diffuser/lampshade, no?
- WalterBright 6y agoTake a look at welding goggles: https://www.amazon.com/YESWELDER-Powered-Darkening-Welding-Grinding/dp/B07Y6244WP https://www.amazon.com/YESWELDER-Powered-Darkening-Welding-G... and think of all the electric power wasted trying to block that light. Besides the crackling/buzzing sounds, and the toxic smoke wafting off of it, and trying to keep it from setting fire to your drapes. No thanks, I'll take an Edison bulb for the win!
- Retric 6y agoAll fluorescent bulbs are just a specific subtype of Arc lamps. In the 1970’s plenty of different gasses where being used in Arc Lights. For example in 1860, John Thomas Way used arc lamps operated in a mixture of air and mercury vapor which eventually evolved into mercury vapor lamps which where invented before Edison, but the first popular variation was invented in 1901. Also a fairly thin sheet of glass blocks most of the UV, welding masks are thick and dark because welding produces a lot of light and you want significant eye protection from shards etc. Modern ARC lamps are bright specifically because we have incandescent bulbs when you want less light.
- Retric 6y ago> In the 1970’s Ops, 1870’s
- WalterBright 6y agoEdison's bulbs pretty much created the lighting industry. Arc lighting was nowhere near as useful. Why would Edison have even bothered if arc lights were plenty good enough?
- Retric 6y agoIt’s the same basic reason people use incandescent bulbs at home. They Mercury etc Lamps might last longer and be more efficient, but incandescent bulbs produce more pleasing light, started up faster, don’t flicker, are quite, etc. They where very much an improvement for home use, but the lighting market was fairly large by the time Edison’s bulbs showed up, which is what allowed for such rapid growth.
- WalterBright 6y ago> the lighting market was fairly large by the time Edison’s bulbs showed up Not really, as Edison needed to install a generator even to light up his bulb coming-out party, and needed to come up with a central generator to electrify city blocks because people wanted his bulbs, not arc lamps. Edison's bulbs, with their high resistance, used far less electric power than arc lamps.
- Retric 6y agoThat quote is about low voltage technology. Edison’s design changed dramatically over time, his early bulbs used a carbon filament just like the quoted example. Tungsten bulbs invented by Franjo Hanaman in 1904 where a significant improvement on that design and he’s arguably the actual inventor of modern incandescent lightbulbs. Similarly, the gasses uses inside bulbs and the filament design all changed significantly over time. PS: Arc lamps like florescent bulbs are “high voltage, low current design” however all early incandescent bulbs where low voltage. Edison improved the design of low voltage bulbs, but he hardly invented the idea.
- WalterBright 6y agoUm, I said Edison's innovation was a high voltage, low current design. Not the other way around.
- Retric 6y agoI am pointing out high and low is a relative scale. Relative to neon lights or other arc lamps all incandescents are low voltage.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe other incandescent bulbs at the time used low resistance, high current bulbs, which consumed far too much power.
- Retric 6y agoHis direct competitor at the time had a patent out 1 year sooner, entered mass production one year later, had as you say lower resistance. (Blanking on the name). Prior to this various different bulbs where created that had more or less resistance. It was a wild time period prior to centralized power distribution.