4 ms·
Nuance in mass communications, especially in high-consequence circumstances, is itself a major risk factor. Drawing a very bright, very wide, strongly-enforced
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Nuance in mass communications, especially in high-consequence circumstances, is itself a major risk factor.
Drawing a very bright, very wide, strongly-enforced safety line well away from any potential hazard has value.
Public health in pandemics is all about consistently breaking transmission chains. And even countries with initial or eventual success can remain at risk of resumed high infection rates, as is evident currently in India (doubling daily infections over a week: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/india/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/india/), Turkey, Brazil, Poland, Germany, and in parts of the US (notably Michigan, at this writing).
- ghaff 6y agoOf course, it doesn't mean people will follow rules they don't feel make sense. Where I live in Massachusetts masks are required in all public spaces whether distanced or not. But my anecdotal observation in the state forests, etc. around where I live is that most people don't when they're well-distanced from everyone. And they may pull up a neck gaiter for a few seconds if they're passing someone on a trail (especially if that other person is wearing a mask).
- dredmorbius 6y agoIf I were managing public health in a region ... I'd probably be reasonably comfortable with that behaviour. But in a world in which modest and reasonable requests to wear masks result in angry outbursts to murderous rage ... I could also be convinced to draw a firmer line. Again: the matter is nuanced.
- ghaff 6y agoThere's no real enforcement anyway though. We're talking about large outside recreational areas in exurban/rural areas. And even passing on trails, people are almost always at least 6 feet away. Also, as I say, people are mostly good about pulling something up if approaching a masked group, even if it's mostly theater. My understanding is that closer to the city, more people are wearing masks outdoors but the walking paths are more crowded as well.
- bitcurious 6y ago> But in a world in which modest and reasonable requests to wear masks result in angry outbursts to murderous rage ... On the other hand, that rage (but not murderous) is justified if the request isn’t based in any reasonable understanding of disease spread and is just an expression of power over that individual. Such as outside in the woods.
- timeslip1523 6y agoThe anger derives from the unreasonable requests.
- orangecat 6y agoDrawing a very bright, very wide, strongly-enforced safety line well away from any potential hazard has value. It also has harms: it decreases respect for rules that actually do make sense, and it can encourage people to substitute more dangerous activities. If Alice values taking a walk outside without a mask at 50, walking with a mask at 30, and going to a shopping mall (with a mask) at 40, strictly enforcing outdoor mask mandates is going to make her both less happy and more at risk.
- dredmorbius 6y agoDuring a worldwide rapidly-evolving public health emergency of (one desperately hopes) limited duration, that arguments loses sufficient legs to be rendered a snake in the grass.