3 ms·
An intrinsic characteristic of novel threats is that their characteristics are not fully known and understood. Understanding evolves. Other factors include va
by dredmorbius 6y ago
An intrinsic characteristic of novel threats is that their characteristics are not fully known and understood. Understanding evolves.
Other factors include various forms of denial and seeking of agency, amongst both experts and authorities, and the public.
The fomite hypothesis --- that small viral fragments on surfaces might be transmitted to individuals --- was plausible and had some initial credibility. It's been observed elsewhere.
The alternative hypothesis, that the SARS-COV-2 virus was predominantly airborne and spread readily ... was also plausible and had initial credibility, but also meant that the potential threat and consequences of the disease were far greater, a possibility that numerous entities early in the pandemic seemed eager to play down (and many still do). Notably the first official responses in China, the previous administration's response in the US, and both official and lay/media resposnes elsewhere in the US, Brazil, the Phillippines, throughout Europe, and more.
When faced with a novel, difficult-to-perceive threat, one that does not manifest clearly, whose behaviour and characteristics are unknown, people's first response is often to seek the comfort of some degree of control or agency. Cleaning, or hygiene theatre, is just that.
Mind: it's all but certainly not harmful. It may detract from other interventions, though for the most part (and after some early bobbles that were a mixture of good intentions, poor understanding, and supply shortages), the general public health advice was the triad of "wear a mask, wash your hands, stay home." All sensible and still highy recommended.
Cleaning is also a manifest and tangible signifier of a heightened infection risk environment, and one which might have positive carry-overs to other preventive measures and general awareness.
(Lacquering your premises frequently with Lysol not so much, though again, in a potential benefits vs. potential risks calculus, not an entirely bad call.)
So the frequent cleaning recommendation arose from:
- Initial ignorance of transmission mechanisms.
- An unwarranted hope for contract rather than airborne transmission.
- A general advisability for the measure regardless.
- A sense of agency in the face of an unknown and invisible threat.
You can take those circumstances and responses and see them in many other areas. "Hygiene theatre" has obvious connotations with anti-terrorism air travel "security theatre", and I suspect that various technologists will find that their own development and use practices involve various aspects of development theatre, risk theatre, management theatre, etc. These are inherent to any complex phenomena in which relevant and crucial aspects are not overtly evident, and are what give rise to cargo culting and fad-driven practices.
- clairity 6y agono, the rational mistake you're making is assuming there is a safe side to fall on, and moreover defending that position. this kind of thinking is endemic to mediopolitical rhetoric, and it's almost always incorrect. in real world conditions, there are multifactorial risks on all sides, and it's a multidimensional optimization problem. there's just no safe side. the obessiveness over cleaning and its ill effects just being one small element in that multidimensionalism. we need to strive to make the optimal tradeoff, not the mediopolitically mediated safe choice, which we see backfire again and again in practice via unintended consequences, particularly by eroding trust in each other and our institutions, but in many other dimensions as well.
- dredmorbius 6y agoUnsupported presumptions of others' beliefs are exceeding fraught ground. That may be a logic you encounter in others. It is not mine. Hygiene practices haven't been harmful, hence, they're a safe choice. They weren't especially useful. As far as misallocated resources, the general disinformation and misinforation campaigns and amplification in various quarters has been vastly more significant.
- clairity 6y agomore chemicals, diversion, stress, and mistrust, to name just a few, are harmful, and none of those practices were useful.
- ryanlol 6y ago> it's all but certainly not harmful Fuck yeah it has been. Many gyms around the world have reduced their opening times due to increased cleaning requirements, leading to more crowding. I can’t go do my lifts at 2AM anymore because it doesn’t make sense to have cleaning staff around at a time when the gym would normally be almost empty.