6 ms·
Amazon moving into these impovershed areas, becoming the majority employer, and having absolute influence over the local governance and electorate they themselv
by asdff 6y ago
Amazon moving into these impovershed areas, becoming the majority employer, and having absolute influence over the local governance and electorate they themselves employ makes these places de facto a company town. Brilliant move, totally evil genius move, but brilliant.
- johncessna 6y agoThat's what they did in Seattle.
- musingsole 6y agoCarpetbaggers carpetbagging is a story as old as time. At least they're creating jobs and distributing money into the community. It's not like there's a long list of others who would willingly pick up the slack if they went elsewhere.
- gruez 6y agoSo let me get this straight: companies shouldn't be investing money into revitalizing impoverished areas?
- tablespoon 6y ago> So let me get this straight: companies shouldn't be investing money into revitalizing impoverished areas? No, they should do so, just not be so exploitative about it (e.g. deliberately going into areas full of desperate people, for the reason of using that desperation to exert maximum control with minimum accountability).
- mariksolo 6y agoSo your issue is specifically with the mindset of the company, not the actions themselves? Why would a company ever do anything out of the goodness of their hearts? Shouldn't we just be looking at the result of them following market incentives?
- praptak 6y agoOf course companies don't do anything out of the goodness of their hearts. Companies will do as much evil as they are allowed to and as much good as they are forced to. The society should act accordingly.
- mariksolo 6y agoYou're missing my point on purpose. I am trying to say there is a contradiction in what you are saying. You claim to want companies to move into impoverished areas, but also say doing that is evil. No company has ever moved into an impoverished area to help people, they have always done so out of self interest. So which do you want, companies to move into impoverished areas (acting evil), or not (acting good, according to you).
- praptak 6y agoI want strong labor protection laws everywhere, so that poor regions don't have to compete on allowing companies to exploit the local workforce.
- awillen 6y agoLike a $15 minimum wage? The one Amazon is paying?
- lupire 6y agoAnd paying for time spent in security checkpoints, and not counting "walking from workstation to break room" as break time, and compensation for workplace injuries.
- mariksolo 6y agoYou've completely changed the direction of the argument.
- s1artibartfast 6y ago
- lotsofpulp 6y agoHave you ever shopped around for lower pricing? The collective population of the world does this when we chose to purchase things for cheaper prices made in countries with more lax environmental and labor laws.
- tablespoon 6y ago> Have you ever shopped around for lower pricing? It's one thing to shop for a lower price, it's quite another to notice someone's desperate and take advantage. > The collective population of the world does this when we chose to purchase things for cheaper prices made in countries with more lax environmental and labor laws. An a lot of people object to that, too, and they often lack the power to make any other decision.
- bluGill 6y agoWhen you shop around for price you are shopping around for someone to exploit with the lower price. There is no difference, zero sum, if you get a product for less, somewhere in the world someone got less money.
- lupire 6y agoThe difference is plausible deniability, I guess.
- astrange 6y agoThe economy isn't zero sum (from a capitalist PoV) and reducing someone's profit margin isn't exploiting them (from a Marxist PoV). It's important to avoid thinking partial equilibrium effects are the actual effects of something.
- bluGill 6y agoThis isn't about the total ecconomy, this is a single transaction.
- missedthecue 6y agoThe lowest paid person at Amazon is earning well over the median wage in Bessemer, Alabama. Amazon could probably have no problem staffing the center at $11/hr there, but they're paying $18-$22 instead. How on earth can you define that as 'exploitation'? It's borderline charity, given the observable labor market equilibrium there.
- uoaei 6y agoPaying someone more money does not make working conditions less exploitative.
- lupire 6y agoIs the lowest Amazon job as easy and safe as the below median jobs in Bessemer? Speedwalking an Amazon warehouse carrying objects, run by hyper-optimizing automation that times tasks to the second, is different from leaning on idle cash register at McDonalds, or slowly pushing a vacuum cleaner.
- clevergadget 6y agointentionally missing the point about the amount of control in the hands of unelected management but ok kid
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoIt's complicated. When you're the only game in town you enter an ethical gray area where the community is your hostage. Things seem alright now but what happens when the mines run dry?
- astrange 6y agoIs Amazon a monopsony employer in this town? It sounds like they aren't since their warehouse created 1500 jobs and the population is 27000.
- akiselev 6y agoAssuming 60% of the population is employed (roughly more than the US average), that's just under a tenth of the workforce of 16k. Assuming 50% of the workforce is employed by small businesses (slightly more than national average), that makes them a fifth of all people employed by companies large enough to afford to really push local politics around. It's enough numbers to swing most controversial issues It's not company town level of influence, though. A defining feature of which IIRC is that the company owned most or all other businesses in the town and often extracted most of the workers wage through extortionate pricing of basic goods and services.
- yocheckitdawg 6y agoWhat a ridiculous way of looking at it. Companies are damned if they do, damned if they don't in the eyes of some, just by the very fact that they are a private entity motivated to make a profit. Nevermind the fact that from my eyes looking at America from overseas, it seems like companies are the only institutions/organisations that are functioning even remotely in a socially optimal way. Your government is a disaster and couldn't meaningfully manage the pandemic at all, academia is a disaster and is bankrupting your future, military is a disaster and has heavily underinvested in next generation weapons programs so they could spend more time bombing the middle East, your unions are self-serving enterprises (aren't schools in your most populous state STILL closed due to teacher's unions?), your newspaper are incredibly corrupt across the spectrum. The only things that seem to work correctly are your companies which are still world-leading and world class. Amazon is a gem in your society, but demonised as if it is the source of all problems.
- akira2501 6y ago> companies shouldn't be investing money into revitalizing impoverished areas? Isn't that what taxes are for?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoWhere do you think taxes come from?
- akudha 6y agoDidn't Walmart do this in a lot of small towns? And sometimes just pack up and leave? What happens when they leave?
- TuringNYC 6y ago>> Didn't Walmart do this in a lot of small towns? And sometimes just pack up and leave? What happens when they leave? I think a good question to ask before is what happens if they dont come in the first place? If I were a resident in a town wanting jobs, i'd probably be more excited about jobs arriving than the possibility they might eventually disappear.
- akudha 6y agoI dunno, there doesn't seem like a simple answer to this. If the choice is between starving or working for a heartless/soulless corporation doing the bare minimum, the system has failed miserably
- asdff 6y agoWalmart doesn't go in blind, they are in the business of extraction. Typically they look to setup a regional store in an area where towns already have optometrists, florists, sporting goods stores, grocers, bakers, homegoods, electronics, hardware, autoparts, the entire town basically. What happens if they didn't come in the first place is life continues in a more decentralized and localized manner, and less of the taxable profit is carted out of the county. Presumably these optometrists and sporting goods store owners of the past paid their income and property taxes from their salaries locally in the area.
- galkk 6y agoAmazon is situated in Seattle, and the incompetence and corruption of goverment here is well-known. I wouldn't search for evil intent in those moves.
- snarf21 6y agoThe way to solve this is with Federal worker's rights reforms specifically around working conditions. It is hard to see that happening with the government very pro-corporation right now.