5 ms·
Apple Never Made iMessage for Android to Lock in iOS Users
- wpietri 6y agoThis just makes me mad. Over the years extended family members have spent a lot on replacement iPhones for kids when what they really wanted to get for them was cheap Android phones.
- evgen 6y agoThe idea that iMessage was the lock-in factor here is absurd. No one purchased an iPhone specifically to get access to iMessage.
- jonwinstanley 6y agoThis seems so odd to me, the UK as a country switched to WhatsApp due to there always being a decent % of Android users amongst all groups of friends
- draw_down 6y agoI don't typically expect companies to light money on fire (including future money), but maybe that's just me
- tannhaeuser 6y agoHuh? iMessage transparently integrates and falls back to SMS from any phone, Android or not, even dump phones (or iPhones without iCloud login for that matter).
- Philadelphia 6y agoYeah, completely don’t understand this. Do they mean FaceTime?
- mattzito 6y agoNo, they mean iMessage - it's true iMessage falls back to SMS, but a lot of fidelity is lost. Reactions don't work, there's no stickers, images are lower resolutions, videos are potato quality, read receipts don't work. It's not complete incompatibility, but it's a much worse experience compared to what fully native users get.
- atom-morgan 6y agoOther than images and videos degrading, I'm always surprised by the number of people who care so much about iMessage. Is it even the extra features or do people primarily care about blue/green bubbles?
- dangus 6y agoFor me it's send reliability, delivery/read receipts, and file size limits (the aforementioned video/image/GIF quality). Those are all surmountable things with chat apps and other third party software, but the beauty of iMessage is that I can make all that work with all my non-technical family members without having to explain anything. I can't get my parents to install something like Discord or Signal. iMessage also recently introduced threading, and although it's not as good as something like Slack it's nice to have. Some other nice features include sharing of attachments that MMS doesn't support like PDF files and contact cards. The next big advantage is that seeing a blue bubble when you type in a phone number or receive a message is a relatively reliable indicator that you're about to talk to a human on a real cell phone and not a bot or spammer.
- twobitshifter 6y agoIt would be great for the world to get iMessage on Android, maybe it would serve to erode the stranglehold of WhatsApp in many countries. From a business perspective it still might not make sense, but many iPhone users are now using WhatsApp and Facebook messenger over iMessage. Android users around the world rarely use These same apps over sms to an even greater extent. This means Apple is losing market share on their own platform. If this continues, the lock-in they fought for is gone. Will families still feel they’re unable to buy an Android phone for their kid when they talk to everyone on Facebook messenger?
- simonh 6y agoI used to just use iMessage, but then my mother got a Samsung. We've all pretty much transitioned to WhatsApp as a result. It's more convenient to just use one app for all our chat even though most of our phones are iPhones.
- atat7024 6y agoand Facebook owns it. Highly recommend Signal as a great upgrade.
- jonwinstanley 6y agoWhy would it lock them in? There are a ton of other free messaging apps
- happynacho 6y agoPeople will use what their friends and family already have. So if everyone uses iMessage but you.. that's lock-in explained.
- meepmorp 6y agoOh my god! I can't believe Apple would make the entirety rational decision to not make iMessage for Android because there's no good reason for them to do so.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 6y agoThere are plenty of good reasons. If your point is they're only going to listen to the reasons that involve them making more money, I'm sure you're right. But at some point that becomes anticompetitive behavior.
- meepmorp 6y agoNo, there aren't any good reasons. If you want iMessage, get an iPhone. Similarly, if you want to sideload apps, get an Android. You're not entitled to everything you want because you want it.
- wpietri 6y agoOh? If you're so confident, surely you can demonstrate that there are zero good reasons. I'll wait.
- meepmorp 6y agoHere I enumerate the set of reasons that Apple would make and maintain an iMessage client for Android, G, such that for every reason r in G, r is a good reason: G = {} The cardinality of the set G is zero, QED.
- wpietri 6y agoI guess if you're not going to take your point seriously, there's no particular need for me to. But maybe save your limp comedy for Reddit next time.
- callesgg 6y agoWell the fact that they could is obvious. But the fact that people at apple are stating it publicly is somewhat peculiar.
- olliej 6y agoLet's turn this around. What is the reason for apple to make an android port?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- emsy 6y agoThey can't have a lot of confidence in their product being superior when they have to resort to these kind of tricks. I mean I knew about the lock-in but this actively makes me want to avoid Apple products.
- tbihl 6y agoI've frequently looked at switching to an iphone for the longer software support, but iMessage is a consistent deal breaker. As I understand it, you can't set a default SMS app. In my case, I can't use Signal as a secure platform that falls back to SMS for compatibility.
- BugsJustFindMe 6y agoI approach this from the other side. I always want to be completely in control over how a message gets sent because the different mechanisms all have unique failure reliability modes. If I want to send an SMS I go to the SMS app. If I want to send through Signal I go to Signal. That way I'm never surprised by my phone doing something unexpected like trying to use a flaky data stream instead of piggybacking on tower traffic or vice versa.
- 908B64B197 6y agoRemember BBM? That was what BlackBerry tried as a last ditch effort. They believed that people would stay in their ecosystem so they could keep BBM. What they failed to understand that the real professional users were all on Bloomberg Chat, the one platform where the people who matters are. And teenagers didn't care for BBM: As soon as one of their friends got an iPhone, they had to ditch it for Messenger or WhatsApp anyways.
- nikau 6y agoNot sure this theory holds water. Corporate use was the bread and butter of blackberries because the BES server provided end to end encryption. This was separate to consumer blackberries where the encryption keys were manged by blackberry themselves (BIS). blackberries were replaced replaced by iphone and android devices once similar encryption was available, and was pushed even harder once BYOD was viable with its associated cost savings.
- 908B64B197 6y agoEven before BYOD, I remember hedge funds giving out iPhones for their employees. Was a signaling move since everyone wanted one.
- lucasyvas 6y agoIANAL, but for those asking why Apple should be expected to port iMessage to Android, I believe that is possibly missing the point. Epic is probably using iMessage lock-in as a supporting argument for anti-competitive behaviour from Apple. It doesn't necessarily matter beyond Apple's self admission that they exhibit this behaviour in more than one way.