5 ms·
Facebook axes 16,000 groups for trading fake reviews after UK intervenes
- yonaguska 6y agoWill they go after all the coyotes advertising human smuggling service?
- Ceezy 6y agoAre you talking about actual human trafficking? Do you have a link?
- envy2 6y agoNo, he's talking about the politically-charged issue of people discussing services to help voluntary migrants get into another country. But, at least in the case of Facebook, advertising/offering those services isn't allowed[1], but discussing them is; this is a bit of a fine line, but one that is likely trying to strike a balance between letting people share safety and route information while not allowing potentially exploitative traffickers to solicit victims. [1] https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards/human_exploitation https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards/human_exploitati...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yonaguska 6y ago> people discussing services to help voluntary migrants get into another country. That's a disgusting way to frame the plight of minors that have no consent in the journey they are coerced into taking. And, no, I'm not talking about people offering advice and posting safe routes. I'm talking about coyotes for cartels promising safe escort for thousands of dollars. Which is a lie. They will let these people die if necessary. Then they'll hold them hostage if they do make it, by threatening to kill their families back home if payment is not received. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/human-smugglers-use-facebook-connect-migrants-spread-false-hope-reaching-n1262984 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/human-smugglers...
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Then they'll hold them hostage if they do make it, by threatening to kill their families back home if payment is not received. I'm struggling to see what you think is odd about trying to collect payment for services already rendered?
- yonaguska 6y agoI'm struggling to see how you don't think this scenario is exploitative. Services rendered may or may not include you being dropped off in the desert with no food, water, and left for dead, being stashed dangerous transport situations, being subject to rape, or forced sex work, being forced into working as a mule or other criminal activity. Children in the holding facilities have been observed engaging in sex acts with each other, indicative of being abused on the journey there. Children are showing up with damaged vocal chords. Women are routinely raped by their smugglers. I'm amazed that every response I'm getting is questioning how what is going on at the border is not human trafficking. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/03/us/border-rapes-migrant-women.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/03/us/border-rapes-migrant-w... We are talking about Facebook providing a platform for advertising for these transactions. Do you remember FESTA/SOSTA, craigslist, and backpage and all the uproar over that? But Facebook gets a pass.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoCome on. What do you think happens when you borrow money from organized crime?
- yonaguska 6y agoWhat is "actual" human trafficking? Do you not consider minors being coerced to make the journey alone not human trafficking? https://www.justice.gov/humantrafficking/what-is-human-trafficking https://www.justice.gov/humantrafficking/what-is-human-traff... https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/human-smugglers-use-facebook-connect-migrants-spread-false-hope-reaching-n1262984 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/human-smugglers...
- Black101 6y agoI don't think that this is something that Facebook is against... so you would need to get a lot of people talking against it for them to do something about it.
- skd-fs 6y agoNot surprising at all at this point. At Fakespot we've noticed a huge surge in fake reviews that originate from Facebook groups where sellers and professional reviewers meet. The way it works is that a seller provides some kind of incentive (gift card, paypal money, etc) to write a 5 star or even 1 star review (for competitors). Facebook has hosted these groups and they have exploded in numbers in the last year.
- liquidpele 6y agoThey also put “you’re a lucky customer” offer cards offering Amazon gift cards with the items. We emailed a hotmail account to get a $15 Amazon card for filling out a review. Then they offered an extra $10 to make it 5 star.
- colejohnson66 6y agoCouldn’t one make the review, take the money, then delete the review after redeeming the card?
- jayrot 6y agoI'd imagine you could but enough people just don't bother that it still ends up worth it.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAnd/or, the set of people who'd have qualms about leaving a fake review, but were perfectly willing to cheat a stranger out of $15, is empty. Not to mention, it would kill an opportunity for repeat business.
- Ceezy 6y agoJust wondering, is anyone happy with FB ad/recommendation tools? Cause a friend in the ad business was telling that FB ad never perform and she stoped.
- strulovich 6y agoI have a friend who works on ads for video games mostly. Their company uses Google and Facebook for the majority of those spend, which one has better value for money tends to change every time I ask them. They definitely made FB ads work well for them for many years. In addition, I’ve noticed people here commonly tell stories about how X’s ads never work work. I find it ridiculous. All of those digital ads definitely work for many companies, even if they don’t work at all for others. Ads is a competitive market. If your ads don’t work, it doesn’t say much about the platform, and may say more about your ads/product. (Disclaimer: FB employee, but I don’t deal with ads)
- knuthsat 6y agoThe only way ads can work today is that the ad system takes the metric from the user. If someone is tweaking the keywords and other things on their own the ads will very quickly stop working.
- nolok 6y agoI currently buy about 50k worth of ads every month, aiming for qualified leads (my end goal is converted sale, no recurring). FB is one of the worst ad network I've had the displeasure to use. First in terms of analytics and reporting. Adwords plays the "AWS billing card", they're transparent without being so, and the overabondance of unrelated metrics makes it sometime difficult to figure out where you are wasting cash. Still, it appears to be working hand in hand with me, they would like me to overpay what I need, but they also want it to make me money so I come back for more. They're my own personnal crack dealer. Facebook on the other hand really feel like a casino experience. It's basically telling you "it's working ! you should be pleased with the result !" and in general doesn't feel like a pleasant relationship to me. Doesn't surprise me in the least that they were caught many times faking numbers because that's the general vibe it gives off. Second in terms of results. Talking to other people in the field it appears to perform decently for retargeting, or to grab a mass volume traffic/eyeballs. And they make lots of billions so clearly there is value to get there. But for high value qualified leads, FB is basically the same as Adwords "display network", which is already known as the crappy terrible part of adwords you should probably not use. Doesn't really surprise me, on Google/Amazon/Bing you're appearing in front of someone who typed "amazon I need a water pump" or "google I need a pdf editor", you're answering the user's question. Whereas on FB just like display network you just appear on content or for users that are vaguely related, you're bothering the user more than anything. Like everything Ads it depends on your product and your market and how much time you can spend on it, but for me it's a massive dud. Again, everything written here is my own experience and preference, I might be using it wrong, YMMV, lots of people make lots of money of it and all that.
- patorjk 6y agoI had a friend who was doing this. The way it worked is there was a secret FB group where items would be posted, and if you were up for reviewing the item you'd message the group coordinator who would send you money to buy it. You'd then buy and review the item. Initially you would only be reviewing small items ($5-$10), but as you gained more trust you could get more expensive items (not sure what the limit was). Some items even came with an additional $20 for doing a review. I cautioned them that what they were doing was a good way to get their Amazon account suspected (I didn't even think about their FB account) and they eventually did stop. Most of what they accumulated was crap, but there were a hand full of nice items - though thinking about it now, the only thing they got that I thought was cool was a decorative snail statue.
- NullPrefix 6y ago>I cautioned them [...] and they eventually did stop They did stop letting you know about it
- reaperducer 6y agoChances are this person knows his friend and how that friend acts a lot better than some rando on the internet does.
- slig 6y agoSurely a person that posts fake reviews online in exchange of money and/or goods wouldn't lie.
- loceng 6y agoIt's why public/published reviews/testimonials for general public consumption are bunk. Lower quality, crappier or knockoff product, will have higher profit margin to afford marketing/advertising and other tactics like fake reviews. Word of mouth reviews from your trusted tribe leaders, go-to people you come to learn to trust (vs. random internet stranger), slows down processes but inherently has quality-trust built into the process. I am a fan of a lot of what Tesla and Elon has done, not a fan of others parts of the whole, however what I think I value the most so far is that Tesla doesn't advertise: the attention they've gained has arguably been deserved and not bought. This is a very powerful and important mechanism that society hasn't understood yet, and needs a Facebook->The Social Dilemma moment to bring to light of the cascading consequences of the Ad industrial complex - of people being able to cheaply buy attention they haven't earned nor deserve (for products and services). En mass this industrial complex is funnelling money into feeding this low quality, bad actor tactic system - and away from honest, high-quality, deserving individuals, organizations/companies, and systems. With the correct policy we can quickly knock out likely 4 or even 5 birds with a single stone; more likely it's 10 policies fix/shift 3x the systems that need fixing from their foundation. UBI, a share/dividend from just some of the productivity of the society paid back to the largest cog in the wheel of capitalism, will be one such policy - that then applied with say 9 other policies and/or systemic changes - will then each compound with the others giving a 100x improvement.
- illwrks 6y agoThis will move to other placeslike Discord
- quantumwannabe 6y agoHeadline changed to: "Facebook axes 16,000 groups for trading fake reviews after UK intervenes". Sounds like they just banned the groups, not the accounts in them like the original title said.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoWhat are the EU/UK rules like for people who get banned but have purchased hardware that only works if you have an FB account (like an Oculus headset)? I think in the US you're SOL if you get banned outside of the return and chargeback windows
- ipaddr 6y agoI guess one would need to resell the Oculus or use it as a movie prop. If I got an Oculus I would immediately stop using facebook for fear of a random account problem preventing my expensive hardware from working.
- Kbelicius 6y agoDon't know about EU but Oculus is not selling in Germany because it requires an FB account.
- rush86999 6y agoshameless plug - started a subreddit r/shouldibuythisproduct to ask other members with history if a product is worth buying. Sometimes just knowing a brand is trustworthy or not is enough to make a good buying decision along with product specs. https://www.reddit.com/r/shouldibuythisproduct/ https://www.reddit.com/r/shouldibuythisproduct/
- imglorp 6y agoWhat's going to keep all these shills out when they find out about it?
- rush86999 6y agogood question: here's a response I made on the reddit People might think that this might be another system that might get gamed. If someone tries hard enough, they can play the long game, and game the system. The point is user karma and user history should be enough to make it harder to game the system. Once there is enough traffic, there will strong moderation and minimum posting/commenting requirements Also another response to bribing the influencers of the system: Bribe could work but as long as the product is not crap, I think there is no perfect model. The influencers will still have to worry about keeping a reputation and if they put their name on a crappy product they will lose their reputation. People will start pointing this out. Karma might make them stand out and face more criticism for being in the limelight. You also make a good point. Maybe it should be shouldibuythisbrand?
- ipsum2 6y agodang or other mod, can you correct the title? Reuters modified the article: > (Corrects headline, paragraph 1 to say Facebook “removes”, not “suspends”, 16,000 “groups”, not “accounts”) > (Reuters) - Social media company Facebook Inc removed 16,000 groups for selling or buying fake reviews of products and services on its platforms, after the Britain’s competition watchdog intervened for the second time, the regulator said.
- dang 6y agoYup. Fixed now. Thanks!