4 ms·
Reading the website with my startup founder hat on: -------- — HAS YOUR BUSINESS AN EXCEL PROBLEM? No. I'm good at Excel. — DO YOU HAVE HUNDREDS OF UNMANAGE
by onion2k 6y ago
Reading the website with my startup founder hat on:
--------
— HAS YOUR BUSINESS AN EXCEL PROBLEM?
No. I'm good at Excel.
— DO YOU HAVE HUNDREDS OF UNMANAGED SHEETS RUNNING REPORTS?
Not really. I keep telling people to put files in the right Google Drive folders and one day very soon they definitely will, but we get by and so far it's not been a big problem.
— DO THEY TELL YOU IT WOULD TAKE TOO MUCH TIME TO REPLACE WITH PROPER APPS?
Excel is a proper app.
--------
I think a big part of your messaging comes across like you're assuming the people who need your app are a bit stupid. You seem to think people can't workaround the problem your app tries to solve. They can, obviously, because they're running their businesses day to day. You need to push the reason why your app is a better solution rather than why Excel is bad (which it clearly isn't considering how many businesses use it for reporting).
Also, "UNLIKE EXCEL, JIG FILES ARE AUDITABLE"... I'm not 100% sure what you mean by auditable there, but Excel has features for auditing formulae. https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/display-the-relationships-between-formulas-and-cells-a59bef2b-3701-46bf-8ff1-d3518771d507 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/display-the-relat...
- DocTomoe 6y ago> — DO THEY TELL YOU IT WOULD TAKE TOO MUCH TIME TO REPLACE WITH PROPER APPS? This might be just me and my professional circle, but we understand "app" as a toy that runs on a phone. Apps, by definition, are never "proper". We would never replace Excel with an APP. We might replace Excel with a "program" or a "system", or even a "framework".
- d--b 6y agoWhat you may not know, is that a lot of people use Excel as an app container.
- pdenton 6y agoYou mean, I already had a Docker in 1997?
- d--b 6y agoPretty much. In all seriousness, it was used a bit like that. I know of a bank who set up excel "farms". You'd start a bunch of computers somewhere. Send them a spreadsheet. Have Excel open them and run some macros. Get back the results. They would do it to calculate various scenarios that took a long time to run. That was 2007...
- johnchristopher 6y agoOne could day Excel was /is an ok-ish database builder with integrated editor and real time output.
- d--b 6y agoNo, that's not where I am coming from. I come from major banks and financial industries behemoths who run trading books handling billions of dollars on excel spreadsheets. Are they stupid? God, no! They do it, cause there's no better alternative. They just don't have the time to use anything fancier. There is a European Research group that is funded to tackle what they call "spreadsheet risk", cause at some point, yes Excel becomes a problem. EDIT: btw, auditing here means that you can't easily know what changed between 2 versions of a spreadsheet, unless you're extremely careful about how you write your sheet.
- sails 6y agoAlso working in and around banking, this is a huge issue. Terrifying. Fat finger mistakes are rampant. I think you are on the right problem, but your solution is too much built for you and not for the people creating the problem (low-tech analysts). Think you did get enough feedback here though, so I won't try add anything. Sadly I think this Excel issue feels so unlikely to get better any time soon. Institutions teach students using Excel, businesses use Excel. The analysts of 10 years in the future are learning Excel today, not python/pandas/R
- sails 6y agoMy only 2c: Your product from first glance looks like a Spyder python IDE. That immediately turns me away from using it as I'd rather use a Jupyter Notebook, or a Streamlit app, or even better than both I've been testing the hex.tech app which really solves the problem you are working on. I think your issue isn't building the wrong thing but rather perhaps being unaware of the alternatives in the "internal data questions" space, let alone the Business Intelligence tooling space.